Sam Fleming, the FT economics editor, shares insights into Labour's challenges as the party grapples with a projected £22 billion deficit. He highlights the difficult balance of increasing taxes while maintaining voter support. The discussion delves into the political climate, revealing struggles within party leadership and the urgency of effective governance. They also touch on the Tory leadership race and the need for Labour to communicate its vision of hope amidst the gloom, examining the broader implications for UK economic and diplomatic relations.
Labour's grim narrative on the economy, while rooted in reality, risks alienating the public if not countered with positive messaging.
Starmer's diplomatic efforts to normalize UK-EU relations post-Brexit highlight a cautious approach, emphasizing reputation over immediate economic gains.
Deep dives
Budget Expectations and Economic Challenges
The discussion centers around the financial strains facing the government as it prepares for a difficult budget. Keir Starmer has warned that upcoming decisions will be painful, raising questions about the effectiveness of expectation management strategies. The Labour Party's narrative has shifted towards highlighting the dire economic situation inherited from previous administrations, which has led to concerns about how realistic these claims are. Analysts suggest that the painful measures anticipated might not resonate well with the public, particularly given the perception of inconsistent financial management.
Taxation Strategies and Fiscal Responsibility
The podcast highlights the looming fiscal black hole of £22 billion that the Labour government needs to address, particularly through potential tax increases. Rachel Reeves has called for a balanced approach, urging the wealthier individuals to contribute more without drastically affecting middle-income earners. Although some tax reforms were considered, such as capital gains tax adjustments, significant hurdles remain due to prior commitments to avoid raising major taxes like income tax and national insurance. Experts are deliberating various strategies to fill the gap, including the possibility of targeting specific corporate sectors for tax adjustments.
Political Image and Public Sentiment
The Labour government is facing scrutiny regarding its public image and messaging as it navigates challenging political landscapes. Starmer's governance approach appears cautious and reactive, reflecting a broader sentiment that the public may be growing weary of constant reminders of the government's inherited difficulties. There is a consensus that while highlighting the previous administration's failures is essential, it must be balanced with positive narratives. If the government fails to pivot towards showcasing accomplishments alongside discussing issues, it risks losing public support amid ongoing discontent.
International Relations and European Engagement
Starmer's diplomatic engagements with European leaders have taken center stage as part of Labour's strategy to normalize UK relations post-Brexit. While there's an emphasis on the importance of these meetings, expectations for substantial economic shifts remain tempered due to existing red lines on issues like freedom of movement. The focus appears to be on restoring the UK's image as a cooperative partner, rather than on securing immediate benefits. This resetting of relations may provide a foundation for future negotiations, but tangible outcomes will likely take time and careful maneuvering.
A 'painful' Budget awaits this autumn and things will get 'worse before they get better', Sir Keir Starmer warned this week. But is Labour taking a risk projecting such a gloomy outlook? Political Fix host Lucy Fisher is joined by regulars Stephen Bush and Robert Shrimsley, as well as FT economics editor Sam Fleming, to consider how the new government might fund the fiscal black hole it claims the Tories left behind – and find a message of hope. Plus, the group analyses who’s ahead and who’s falling back in the Tory leadership race.
Follow Lucy on X: @LOS_Fisher, Stephen @stephenkb, Robert @robertshrimsley, Sam @Sam1Fleming
Sign up here for 30 free days of Stephen Bush's Inside Politics newsletter, winner of the World Association of News Publishers 2023 ‘Best Newsletter’ award.
Presented by Lucy Fisher. Produced by Tamara Kormornick with Leah Quinn. The executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound engineering by Jean-Mark Eck with original music by Breen Turner. Broadcast engineering by Andrew Georgiades and Rod Fitzgerald. The FT’s head of audio is Cheryl Brumley.