The Herd with Colin Cowherd Hoops Tonight - SGA vs. Luka debate, why Warriors are struggling, Victor Wembanyama vs. Nikola Jokic | NBA Mailbag
Dec 26, 2025
Dive into the debate of Shai Gilgeous-Alexander versus Luka Doncic as Jason evaluates their performances this season. He breaks down the Warriors' struggles, attributing them to management decisions rather than Steph Curry's play. Explore the differences between offensive stars like Nikola Jokic and two-way players like Victor Wembanyama. Plus, insights on how true shooting percentage impacts team strategy and the growth of players like Shai. This engaging discussion tackles key NBA themes and player evaluations!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Evaluating Players In A Vacuum
- Jason Timpf ranks players in a vacuum, separating individual performance from team context.
- He moved Shai ahead of Luka because Shai's efficiency and reduced turnovers outpaced Luka this season.
Efficiency Shift Explains Player Ranking Flip
- Luka has regressed in efficiency and turnovers, while Shai's true shooting has jumped into the high 60s this year.
- That efficiency gap, not team records, is why Timpf now favors Shai over Luka.
True Shooting Isn't The Whole Story
- True shooting percentage matters, but live-game factors like missed threes and fouls change practical outcomes.
- Missed threes and failed drives can trigger opponent transition chances that raw TS% doesn't capture.