The J. Burden Show

Private Schools Won't Save You w/ George Bagby: The J. Burden Show Ep. 377

6 snips
Nov 26, 2025
George Bagby, an educator and commentator, dives deep into the complexities of private education. He critiques the 'neocon' influence in schools and discusses C.S. Lewis's insights on moral relativism in modern pedagogy. Bagby highlights pressures teachers face, including grade inflation and parental pushback over moral instruction. He passionately defends teaching objective values through classics like Homer and Dante, linking them to civic duty. The conversation navigates the challenges of maintaining educational integrity amid managerial norms.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Debunking Destroys Moral Education

  • George Bagby argues modern education debunks objective value judgments, leaving taste and virtue hollow.
  • This debunking undermines students' capacity to recognize enduring goods and cultural foundations.
ANECDOTE

Teacher Fired Over Upholding Standards

  • Bagby recounts teaching literature and losing his job after clashing with administrators and parents over value-based grading.
  • He says administrators prioritized enrollment and budget over maintaining objective standards.
INSIGHT

Education Shapes Proper Loves

  • Bagby invokes Lewis and Aristotle: education aims to make pupils like and dislike what they ought.
  • Properly ordered loves (Ordo Amoris) are central to social cohesion and education's purpose.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app