PTI Was Notre Dame SNUBBED by the Committee?
Dec 8, 2025
Michael and Tony dive into the controversy surrounding Notre Dame's exclusion from the 12-team playoff picture. They dissect the NFL landscape, focusing on the Chiefs' surprising loss and its impact on the AFC. The duo also looks into key NFC matchups, including a fierce rivalry game and unexpected upsets. Plus, they weigh in on Hall of Fame selections, reflecting on the PED debates surrounding notable names. With a mix of MLB, MLS, and NBA highlights, they wrap up with thoughts on the upcoming Monday Night Football clash.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Committee Favored Conference Status
- The committee prioritized conference representation and recent conference-championship participation over an old head-to-head result.
- Tony Kornheiser argues Notre Dame was penalized for being independent and not having conference protection despite a head-to-head loss to Miami.
Respect Head-To-Head Outcomes
- Honor head-to-head results when making playoff decisions to preserve on-field merit.
- Michael Wilbon insists that if Notre Dame had beaten Miami, they should be included regardless of other factors.
Rankings Reflect Relationships And Memory
- Tony says committee memory and relationships influence rankings week to week, not just game results.
- He highlights the irony of the committee separating Notre Dame and Miami repeatedly yet choosing Miami ultimately.