Katy Balls, a political analyst for The Spectator, joins Isabel Hardman, a political commentator, to tackle the heated debate on Labour's China stance that emerged during Prime Minister's Questions. They discuss Starmer's efforts to assert his position against accusations of softness towards China and the influence of Balls's recent article. The duo also delves into the complexities of political pressures within parties, and Hardman outlines the key arguments surrounding the newly introduced Assisted Dying Bill, highlighting its societal implications.
Starmer faces scrutiny over Labour's perceived softening stance on China, emphasizing cooperation while balancing human rights concerns and internal pressures.
The introduction of the Assisted Dying Bill catalyzes moral and ethical debates among MPs, reflecting deep personal and societal implications that extend beyond legislation.
Deep dives
Labour's Evolving Stance on China
Labour's relationship with China is currently under scrutiny, especially with David Lammy's ongoing visit to the country. Observers note a potential softening in Labour's approach, as senior members like Lammy and Rachel Reeves signal intentions to strengthen ties with China. Despite Labour's tough rhetoric against China, actions suggest otherwise, as Keir Starmer emphasizes cooperation on global issues like climate and trade while facing questions about human rights abuses. This dichotomy raises concerns about how Labour will navigate its foreign policy amidst internal and external pressures regarding its stance on China.
Rishi Sunak's Strategic Questioning
Rishi Sunak opted to emphasize foreign policy during Prime Minister's Questions, a surprising decision given the availability of easier political targets. His queries directed at Keir Starmer concerning China appear calculated, aiming to establish markers for future accountability regarding Labour's foreign policy decisions. Starmer's responses, designed to balance assertions of cooperation with caution around human rights, reflected an underlying tension as he grappled with the risks of appearing too lenient towards Beijing. This exchange illuminated both leaders' difficulties navigating a complex and nuanced geopolitical landscape while under public scrutiny.
Debate on Assisted Dying Legislation
The formal introduction of the assisted dying bill to parliament has sparked significant discussion, with many MPs still undecided on the issue. This topic is especially contentious due to moral and ethical considerations, with interventions from figures like the Archbishop of Canterbury highlighting concerns about potential pressures on vulnerable individuals. Some MPs voiced constituents’ desires for legal assistance in dying, indicating a personal connection to the debate that complicates straightforward political positions. The hope is that this legislative discussion will not only address assisted dying but also prompt broader conversations about quality care for the elderly in society.
Starmer and Sunak debated Labour's position on China at today's PMQs, with Starmer denying going soft on the Asian superpower. Did Sunak draw inspiration from Katy Balls's cover article in last week's Spectator? Katy and Isabel Hardman speak to Oscar Edmondson about the party dynamics behind the debate; how much pressure is each party under from their own China hawks?
Isabel also gives an overview of the debate around the Assisted Dying Bill, which was introduced to Parliament today.
Produced by Patrick Gibbons and Oscar Edmondson.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode