
Post Reports Hegseth defends boat strike; Putin rejects Trump peace plan
6 snips
Dec 5, 2025 Matthew Choi, co-anchor of The Early Brief newsletter, and Michael Birnbaum, a White House reporter, dive into the legality of U.S. military actions against drug-smuggling boats. They discuss Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s controversial orders and the bipartisan scrutiny that followed. The conversation shifts to Trump's peace efforts regarding Russia and Ukraine, contrasting his negotiation style with the complexities of geopolitical relations. Both guests highlight the implications of these actions on Trump's legacy and the administration's shifting justifications.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Controversial Boat Strike Raises War-Law Questions
- The Post reported a U.S. boat strike that killed two survivors clinging to wreckage, prompting legal and ethical questions.
- Experts say killing non-threatening, defenseless people may violate the laws of war and risk bipartisan backlash on Capitol Hill.
Conflicting Official Accounts Hurt Credibility
- Messaging from the White House and Defense Department has been inconsistent about who authorized the second strike.
- Pete Hegseth initially denied involvement, later said he left before the second strike, and points to Admiral Frank Bradley as the decision-maker.
Threat Perception Used To Justify Strike
- Admiral Bradley plans to justify the second strike by saying survivors were climbing back onto the boat and thus posed a threat.
- That framing aims to make the second attack seem like a lawful targeting decision rather than execution of defenseless people.
