The Unprecedented Removal of the U.S. House Speaker … and What’s Next
Oct 4, 2023
auto_awesome
The podcast explores the recent removal of the House Speaker and its implications. It discusses the clash between strong leadership and the division of powers within the U.S. legislative system. The speakers also speculate on potential outcomes of selecting a new House Speaker. They delve into the role of the interim speaker and the potential consequences of not having one. Additionally, they explore the ramifications of a small group determining the functioning of the House compared to the Senate.
The removal of Kevin McCarthy as House Speaker highlights the deep divisions and lack of trust within the Republican caucus in the House of Representatives.
The growing divide between populism and elitism in the Republican Party is evident in the challenge to traditional leadership norms, reflected in conversations about appointing an outsider like Donald Trump as Speaker.
Deep dives
Disagreements and division within the Republican caucus
One of the main reasons for the motion to vacate the speakership and the subsequent removal of Kevin McCarthy as House Speaker is the long-standing disagreements and divisions within the Republican caucus in the House of Representatives. These divisions have been present for several years, with some members expressing resistance to the leadership of the House and to certain policies. McCarthy's agreement to let those who opposed him have seats on the Rules Committee was seen by some as a violation of their agreements, leading to the breakdown in trust.
Populism versus elitism in the Republican Party
Another significant factor in McCarthy's removal as House Speaker is the larger issue of the growing divide between populism and elitism within the Republican Party. There is a sentiment among Republican primary voters of disaffection with Washington and a rejection of the party's establishment. This sentiment was evident in conversations about potentially appointing Donald Trump, who is seen as an outsider and a candidate for office, as Speaker. This challenge to the traditional norms of leadership and governance in the party reflects the changing dynamics and tensions within the Republican Party.
Consequences for the budget process and implications for the House
The removal of Kevin McCarthy as House Speaker has significant implications for the budget process and the functioning of the House. With the continuing resolution set to expire in a few weeks, the lack of a clear leader and the divisions within the Republican caucus could hinder progress on addressing budget issues. The House, which is already disliked by the American public, may face further challenges in maintaining trust and functioning effectively. The uncertainty surrounding the selection of a new speaker and the potential for a prolonged period of debate and conflict adds complexity to the legislative process and raises questions about the future of governance in the House.
The U.S. House is without a Speaker after a small revolt within the Republican Party that removed Kevin McCarthy from that job. With yet another fight over spending just a few weeks away, Cato’s John Samples and Chad Davis explore what might be coming next.