Crime Friday: New Murdaugh Trial Potential, Adult Dwarf or Child Case, and Gypsy Rose's Boyfriend, with Mark Geragos and Jonna Spilbor | Ep. 706
Jan 19, 2024
auto_awesome
Mark Geragos, a renowned defense attorney known for representing celebrities, and Jonna Spilbor, founder of Jonna Spilbor Law, dive into the latest twists in high-profile criminal cases. They examine the possibility of jury tampering in Alex Murdaugh's trial and its implications. The discussion also highlights Gypsy Rose's boyfriend's defense claims of diminished capacity and the bizarre story of Natalia Grace, raising questions about her identity. They wrap up with the strange case of Nicholas Rossi, who allegedly faked his death, adding layers of intrigue to the conversation.
The Alec Murdoch case faced setbacks in its quest for a new trial due to strict ground rules set by the judge and unfavorable legal standards.
The documentary series 'The Curious Case of Natalia Grace' examines the disputed age of a dwarf girl adopted by an American couple, revealing the complexities of her true identity.
The trial of Michelle Traconis focuses on her alleged involvement in the murder conspiracy of Jennifer Dulos, with challenges posed by the lack of a body and the deceased main defendant, Fotis Dulos.
A couple's adoption of a child takes a twist when they believe she's a scammer posing as a six-year-old, resulting in charges of child neglect and a subsequent legal battle over abuse and neglect claims.
Deep dives
The Alec Murdoch Trial: A Bad Week for the Defendant
The hearings for the Alec Murdoch case took place this week to determine if he will get a new trial. The proceedings did not go well for Murdoch, as the judge set strict ground rules that limited the defense's ability to present their case. The defense had hoped for a full-blown hearing with more opportunities for cross-examination, but these expectations were not met. The judge's rulings on the legal standards for determining a new trial were also unfavorable to the defense, making it a challenging week for Murdoch's quest for a new trial.
The Curious Case of Natalia Grace: A Complicated Identity Mystery
The documentary series, 'The Curious Case of Natalia Grace', explores the story of a dwarf girl from Ukraine who was adopted by an American couple. The girl's true age became a topic of dispute, with the adoptive parents uncovering evidence suggesting that she was older than claimed. The series delves into the nuances of the case, including the challenges faced by the adoptive parents and the bizarre twists and turns surrounding Natalia's true identity.
The Jennifer Dulos Trial: Conspiracies and Challenges
Michelle Traconis is currently on trial, accused of conspiracy to commit murder, evidence tampering, and hindering prosecution in the Jennifer Dulos case. The prosecution aims to prove that Traconis conspired with her alleged partner, Fotis Dulos, in the murder of Jennifer Dulos, who went missing during a contentious divorce. The trial poses challenges as the prosecution needs to build a murder case without a body and the main defendant, Fotis Dulos, who died by suicide. The defense will focus on ensuring that the jury understands that Traconis is not on trial for the murder itself but for her alleged role in the conspiracy.
The Controversial Adoption: Questions about Age and Behavior
A couple adopts a child, but soon becomes concerned about her disturbing behavior. They believe she is not the six-year-old they thought she was, but rather a 21-year-old scammer. They move her into an apartment unsupervised but are charged with child neglect. The court revises her birth certificate, but in a twist, she later claims she was actually six years old. She finds a new adoptive family and plans to sue her previous adoptive parents, stating she experienced abuse and neglect.
The Chokehold Case: Self-Defense or Manslaughter?
Daniel Penny is charged with second-degree manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide for using a chokehold on a threatening individual on the subway who later died. The defense argues self-defense, stating that Penny was trying to protect himself and others from the aggressor. The judge denies a motion to dismiss the charges, and the case will go to trial. The outcome is uncertain, considering the complex dynamics, including the racial and self-defense aspects.
The Rise in Crime and Mental Health Crisis in New York City
New York City is experiencing a rise in crime and a significant mental health crisis, particularly within the subway system. Homeless individuals with mental health issues are often left untreated, causing safety concerns for commuters. This situation has sparked debate about the city's approach to criminal justice and mental health services, with many advocating for more aggressive institutionalization programs and improved facilities to address the issue.
The Need for Changes in Leadership and Policies
There is a widespread recognition that changes in leadership and policies are necessary to address the crime and mental health crisis in New York City. Calls for stronger leadership, more effective law enforcement, and increased mental health resources are essential to ensure public safety and address the root causes of the issue. The urgency to make these changes is driven by concerns about the overall well-being and livability of a once vibrant city.
It's true crime Friday on The Megyn Kelly Show, with defense attorneys Mark Geragos and Jonna Spilbor. They discuss whether Alex Murdaugh could actually get a new trial due to jury tampering, whether the tampering affected the verdict, the allegations against Becky Hill, Gypsy Rose's former boyfriend who committed the murder of her mom wanting a new trial now, his lawyer's arguments about diminished capacity, whether Gypsy Rose's release and media tour will help his chances, the bizarre story of Natalia Grace who her adoptive parents said was actually an adult dwarf instead of a child, claims of child neglect, the new revelations that she actually may have been a child after all, whether Grace's adoptive parents could be held criminally or civilly liable, the strange story of Nicholas Rossi, also called Nicholas Alahverdian, who faked his death and fled to the U.K. who is now back in the U.S. awaiting trial, his insistance that he's a different person, the allegations of sexual assault against him, the Daniel Penny case in New York City and the decline of NYC, and more.
Follow The Megyn Kelly Show on all social platforms:
