In this engaging discussion, Yuval Levin, a leading conservative thinker and author, joins to reflect on gratitude and its ties to American conservatism. They tackle the treason of clerks phenomenon impacting institutions today and explore how the exhausted majority can reclaim their political desires. The conversation shifts to Trump’s cabinet nominees and the difficulties of fulfilling big promises in governance. Levin also sheds light on the shifting dynamics of political identity amid growing populism and elitism.
Gratitude is presented as a vital element of conservatism, emphasizing the importance of appreciating ethical institutions that nurture societal flourishing.
The podcast discusses the tension between populism and traditional conservatism, highlighting how populist movements challenge the integrity of established institutions.
Jonah and Yuval explore the differences between leftist optimism and conservative historical commitment, suggesting that awareness of these perspectives is essential for political dialogue.
Deep dives
The Significance of Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving is identified as an essential holiday in American culture, embodying the spirit of gratitude and appreciation for our lives and communities. It serves as a reminder that many of the blessings we enjoy are not solely earned or deserved, but are products of a social and historical achievement that required collective effort over generations. This mindset connects gratitude to humility and a recognition of one’s limitations within a free society. Acknowledging the positive aspects of our lives lays the groundwork for constructive criticism and improvement of societal structures.
Gratitude and Conservative Values
Gratitude is framed as a foundational element of conservatism, reflecting a disposition that celebrates the good in society rather than focusing solely on its flaws. This perspective emphasizes that appreciating the ethical institutions and values that allow people to flourish is crucial, as these achievements are vulnerable and require ongoing commitment. The conservative viewpoint contrasts with leftist narratives, which often view existing structures as oppressive. Consequently, a conservative approach seeks to defend and conserve established principles as essential for nurturing a thriving society.
The Distinction Between Left and Right Politics
The discussion on political ideologies highlights the fundamental differences between leftist and conservative approaches rooted in outlook and historical perspective. Leftist ideologies often project optimism toward future possibilities while overlooking the lessons of the past, whereas conservatives maintain a commitment to building upon historical achievements. This interplay shapes contemporary politics, influencing how both leftist and conservative factions view their identities and responsibilities within society. Understanding these differences is vital for navigating current political tensions and fostering productive dialogue.
The Role of Institutions in Politics
The integrity of institutions is emphasized as a protective mechanism for conserving core societal values, which is increasingly challenged by rising populism. Populist movements often view established systems as sources of oppression, leading to a push against traditional conservatism that seeks to defend these institutions. This dynamic complicates political landscapes as factions within the right and the left maneuver to reshape existing societal structures. The failure to recognize the role of established institutions may jeopardize the foundation necessary for maintaining a civilized society.
Populism and the Future of Conservatism
The influence of populism on modern conservatism raises questions about the direction and coherence of the Republican Party. While populism can mobilize support, it often leads to a departure from core conservative principles and a broader understanding of governance, prioritizing loyalty to personalities over institutional integrity. Future political strategies require a reevaluation of what conservatism means, taking into account the need for coalitional politics that encompasses diverse perspectives. The evolving political environment demands thoughtful leadership capable of reconciling competing ideologies within a unified conservative framework.
As the masses prepare their turkey basters, side dishes, and psyches for Thanksgiving, Jonah is giving thanks to the things he holds most dear: institutions, conservatism, and Yuval Levin.
Yuval and Jonah take some time to express their gratitude for the great American miracle, discuss the treason of the clerks phenomenon plaguing modern institutions, and consider how the exhausted majority can finally get what they want.
Later in the episode, Jonah brings up politics at the table and forces Yuval to cover the smorgasbord of Trump Cabinet nominees, the ineffectual nature of big promises, and the future of coalitional politics.
The Remnant is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including Jonah’s G-File newsletter, weekly livestreams, and other members-only content—click here.