The News Agents What America's first dictator could teach Keir Starmer
58 snips
Dec 12, 2025 Patrick Maguire, Chief political commentator for The Times, dives deep into the lessons Keir Starmer could learn from Huey Long, the controversial Louisiana populist. He critiques Labour's current narrative, arguing that Starmer’s managerial approach lacks a compelling vision. Maguire explores Long's outspoken populism and his revolutionary public works, highlighting how aspirational tradespeople historically fueled such movements. As Maguire predicts potential leadership changes in Labour, he emphasizes the party’s cultural disconnect with voters and the need for a clearer economic direction.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Huey Long's Charming Fabrication
- Huey Long told a false barnyard story to charm Catholic and Baptist voters across Louisiana towns.
- Patrick Maguire uses this anecdote to show Long's theatrical political instincts and voter tuning.
Starmer Lacks Political Authority
- Keir Starmer lacks the political arts and personal authority to impose order on his party.
- Patrick Maguire argues this weakness explains the government's rapid loss of momentum.
Governing Contradicts Opposition Pitch
- Labour's governing choices contradict the image they sold in opposition as a changed, national-interest party.
- Maguire says that mismatch has drained listening from voters and MPs alike.
