80: Apple vs. Beeper: The Battle for iMessage

Dec 15, 2023

Controversy around Android apps enabling iMessage, Beeper Mini uses reverse-engineered iMessage protocols, Apple blocks Beeper Mini, debate on ethical use of fake credentials, desire for iMessage on Android, trust and legal concerns in messaging services, pressure on tech companies to integrate iMessage, iMessage as a gatekeeper, changes in Apple Music, using phone as a sleep aid

Ask episode

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

Introduction

00:00 • 5min

The Use of Fake Credentials and the Implications for iMessage Servers

05:03 • 2min

The Desire for iMessage on Android and the Ethical Debate

06:36 • 6min

Trust and Legal Concerns in Messaging Services

12:17 • 13min

Pressure on Large Tech Companies and the Potential Future of iMessage

25:03 • 4min

iMessage as a Gatekeeper

29:21 • 11min

Reviewing the Apple Music Experience and Exploring iTunes Match

40:03 • 5min

Changes in Apple Music

45:16 • 5min

Using the Phone as a Sleep Aid and Discovering the Sleep Timer Feature

50:36 • 3min

This episode of the MacRumors Show is sponsored by:

Magic Lasso Ad Block- Visit https://www.magiclasso.co/macrumors for a free month trial!

Notion - Visit www.notion.com/macrumors to try the powerful, easy-to-use Notion AI today!

Masterclass - Give one Annual Membership and get one FREE by visiting www.masterclass.com/mac. Offer terms apply!

On this week’s episode of The MacRumors Show, we discuss the recent controversy around Android apps that seek to enable iMessage functionality.Several companies have been vying to offer solutions for Android users who wish to send and receive iMessages for some time. Most recently, “Beeper Mini” offered a way to do so with no need to sign in with an Apple ID.

The app’s developers used reverse-engineered iMessage protocols to register Android phone numbers with Apple’s servers, allowing Android users to send blue bubble messages to iPhoneusers with support for all iMessage functionality, including read receipts, typing indicators, and reactions.Apple ended up blocking Beeper Mini last week, with the company confirming that it took steps to shut down the app since it apparently posed risks to the security and privacy of iMessage users.In a blog post, the Beeper Mini team said that the app had the “fastest growing paid Android application in history,” with more than 100,000 downloads. This was said to be evidence that Android and ‌iPhone‌ customers “desperately want to be able to chat together” with all of the features available on iMessage. Earlier this week, the app’s functionality returned, but now with the requirement to sign in with an ‌Apple ID‌ and receive messages via an email address rather than a phone number.

Beeper Mini’s developers say that despite reaching out to Apple, they have not heard back. It is unlikely that Apple will give in and allow Beeper Mini to function as it did, and Apple may shut down further functionality as well if it can.
Apple does have plans to bring a range of iMessage-like features to chats between ‌iPhone‌ users and Android users through RCS, a protocol that Apple will add to iPhones next year. ‌RCS‌ will bring support for high quality video and images, emoji reactions, typing indicators, read receipts, and more, all features that Beeper Mini says that Android and ‌iPhone‌ users are desperate to have in cross-platform chats.

What do you think about Android apps that enable iMessage functionality? Let us know in the comments.