The NPR Politics Podcast Internal review contradicts Trump administration on Alex Pretti shooting
53 snips
Jan 28, 2026 An internal review challenges the federal account of Alex Pretti’s fatal shooting. Officials’ public statements are compared with agency findings. Lawmakers prepare oversight and bipartisan credibility questions arise. The conversation also covers shifting presidential messaging on immigration, tighter naturalization rules, denaturalization efforts, and how political rhetoric affects safety and civic engagement.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Agency Review Undercuts Official Narrative
- The CBP internal review contradicted Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem's immediate characterization of Alex Preddy as a domestic terrorist.
- Video and the agency's report show officers first confronting two women, then a rapid escalation and shots fired within seconds of claiming Preddy had a gun.
Escalation Happened Within Seconds
- The internal review says agents first shoved two women and only noticed Alex Preddy after that confrontation escalated.
- Agents shouted that Preddy had a gun and fired about five seconds later, suggesting rapid escalation without clear awareness of intent.
Credibility Costs For The Administration
- The disconnect between initial public statements and the agency review damages administration credibility.
- Moderate Republicans and others criticized Secretary Noem, signaling political consequences for the administration's messaging.