Clay Risen, a journalist and historian at the New York Times and author of 'Red Scare,' explores the chilling effects of post-WWII anti-communism in America. He discusses how this movement ruined countless careers in the arts and public service. Risen connects the paranoia of the Red Scare to today's political climate, highlighting the resurgence of conspiratorial politics and its impact on governance. He also touches on the transformation of Hollywood during this tumultuous era, where fear dictated creativity and expression.
The post-World War II Red Scare created a culture of fear that ruined careers across various sectors due to unfounded accusations.
Contemporary far-right movements echo past anti-communist sentiments, highlighting a persistent pattern of conspiratorial thinking in American politics.
Deep dives
Rise of Anti-Communism
In the aftermath of World War II, anti-communist fervor surged in the United States, driven by conservative resentment toward the progressive changes initiated by the New Deal. Many conservatives felt their traditional values were threatened as American society became more pluralistic and inclusive, sparking a cultural backlash against perceived communist influences. This came to a head with the formation of groups like the Minute Women of the USA, who actively opposed policies such as public housing and organized labor rights, which they viewed as signs of communist encroachment. The anxieties of this period fed into a frenzy of accusations and red-baiting that would define the era, often focusing on individuals in government, education, and entertainment who were suspected of communist ties.
The Role of Harry Truman
President Harry Truman played a pivotal role in the expansion of anti-communist measures by implementing loyalty oaths for government employees during his administration. His decisions were largely influenced by the political pressures of the time, as he sought to project strength in confronting the Soviet threat abroad, particularly following the discovery of Soviet espionage in the U.S. government. Despite his initial belief that the threat was overstated, Truman's loyalty programs led to a widespread culture of fear and suspicion, resulting in investigations that often violated the civil rights of countless individuals. The vague criteria used to determine loyalty made it easy for innocent people to be accused, effectively creating a climate where suspicion and paranoia proliferated.
Hollywood's Blacklist
Hollywood became a central battleground in the fight against perceived subversion, marked by the activities of the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC). The committee targeted the entertainment industry, as many believed it harbored radical elements, leading to high-profile hearings that sought to root out communists in film and television. Despite the lack of substantial evidence, individuals like screenwriter Howard Lawson became emblematic of the unyielding nature of these investigations, with many refusing to cooperate under principles of free expression. The result was an informal blacklist that ruined careers, as fear of association with communist sympathizers led many in the industry to betray colleagues or remain silent.
Legacy and Modern Parallels
The Red Scare has left lasting repercussions that can be traced to contemporary political dynamics, where similar patterns of fear and suspicion resurface. The rise of far-right movements can be seen as a continuation of the anti-communist sentiment, with parallels drawn to current views on supposed infiltrations within the government. These sentiments often manifest in accusations of a 'deep state' and a perceived need to dismantle government structures to root out subversive elements. As seen throughout history, this inclination towards conspiratorial thinking can lead to significant political and social consequences, echoing the frenzy of the McCarthy era.
Writer Clay Risen describes a political movement which destroyed the careers of thousands of teachers, civil servants and artists whose beliefs or associations were deemed un-American. His book, Red Scare, is about post-World War II America, but he says there's a throughline connecting that era to our current political moment.
Also, TV critic David Bianculli reviews The Pitt and Adolescence.
