Comic genius, John Cleese, and internationally renowned psychiatrist, Iain McGilchrist, discuss the philosophical and biological underpinnings of how we each understand the world. Topics include the impact of poetry on the body, the struggle of writing and connecting different fields of knowledge, the fallibility of machines, opposing realities rooted in brain structure, the power of attention in shaping perception, the involvement of brain hemispheres in music processing, and the power and limitations of language.
Understanding the differences between the left and right hemispheres helps us comprehend how we engage with reality and perceive the world around us.
The connection between right hemisphere damage and schizophrenia highlights the need for further research to better understand the brain and the experiences of individuals with conditions like schizophrenia.
The role of attention as a fundamental difference between the hemispheres sheds light on our cognitive processes and how we interact with the environment, and paying devoted attention can create a better world.
Deep dives
Importance of Understanding Brain Hemispheres
One of the main ideas discussed in this podcast episode is the importance of understanding the differences between the left and right hemispheres of the brain. The conversation explores how these hemispheres function separately, shaping our perception and relationship with the world. For example, the right hemisphere is more in touch with the body and emotions, understands the implicit and unique, and recognizes tone and facial expressions. In contrast, the left hemisphere focuses on reasoning, language, and making entirely consistent deductions. Understanding these differences helps us comprehend how we engage with reality and perceive the world around us.
The Connection between Right Hemisphere Damage and Schizophrenia
Another key point discussed is the connection between right hemisphere damage and schizophrenia. The podcast highlights that individuals with right hemisphere strokes or damage often exhibit similar phenomena to those with schizophrenia. This includes characteristics such as denial, difficulties with metaphorical and implicit understanding, and reduced awareness of reality. The discussion emphasizes the importance of recognizing these connections and conducting further research and experiments to better understand the brain and the experiences of individuals with conditions like schizophrenia.
The Role of Attention and Its Impact on Perception
The podcast also delves into the role of attention in perception and understanding. It explains how different types of attention are employed by animals and birds for survival purposes. The left hemisphere focuses on narrow, precise attention, while the right hemisphere is responsible for a broader, more holistic attention. The conversation highlights the significance of attention as a fundamental difference between the hemispheres, affecting how we perceive the world and engage with our surroundings. Understanding the role of attention helps shed light on our cognitive processes and how we interact with the environment.
The importance of attention and its role in shaping reality
According to the podcast, attention plays a crucial role in how we perceive and shape our reality. The right hemisphere of the brain is said to be responsible for the holistic understanding of the world, including aspects like melody, rhythm, and harmony in music. In contrast, the left hemisphere is more analytical and focuses on individual moments and details. The podcast suggests that our conscious attention molds our perception of reality, and by paying devoted attention to something, we can bring it to life. The podcast argues that attention can create a better world and defines love as a pure attention to the existence of the other, extending beyond personal relationships to include nature, music, and other experiences.
The limitations of language and the power of non-verbal experiences
The podcast explores the limitations of language and the power of non-verbal experiences in gaining a deeper understanding of the world. It suggests that language is a useful tool for communication and thinking, but there are some aspects of our existence that cannot be fully captured or expressed through words alone. The podcast emphasizes that not everything that exists can be best conveyed or understood through language, and there are experiences like being in love or dealing with loss where language falls short. Humor is proposed as one way to go beyond logical arguments and draw attention to the limitations of purely verbal explanations. The podcast encourages looking beyond language to access a deeper understanding of reality.
What do a comic genius and an internationally renowned psychiatrist have in common? Quite a bit, it turns out. So much, in fact, that Harper’s Magazine and Book Culture on Columbus brought John Cleese and Iain McGilchrist together for two nights of conversation. On the first night, McGilchrist interviewed Cleese; on the second, Cleese interviewed McGilchrist. With wit and intelligence, the two men delved into the philosophical and biological underpinnings of how we each understand the world.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit harpersmagazine.substack.com
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
