László Borhi, "Survival under Dictatorships: Life and Death in Nazi and Communist Regimes" (Central European UP, 2024)
Mar 3, 2025
auto_awesome
László Borhi, an expert in Central Eurasian Studies and author of "Survival Under Dictatorships," dives deep into the harrowing experiences of individuals under Nazi and Communist regimes. He discusses the moral dilemmas faced by victims and the legacy of trauma that lingers through generations. Borhi explores the critical choices made amid fear and oppression, illuminating how individual actions shape history. The conversation reveals striking parallels between totalitarian regimes and emphasizes the relevance of these lessons for understanding contemporary issues.
The podcast emphasizes the significance of personal testimonies in understanding the lived experiences of individuals under oppressive regimes, highlighting their resilience and moral choices.
It explores how the ideological constructs of Nazi and communist regimes dehumanized individuals by categorizing them as enemies, fostering a legacy of fear and trauma that endures across generations.
Deep dives
The Value of Personal Perspective in Studying Dictatorships
The study of dictatorships often overlooks the experiences of ordinary individuals, focusing instead on the perspectives of powerful regimes. A significant theme in the discussion is the importance of understanding history from the viewpoint of the 'little guy,' or the common person affected by authoritarian rule. By utilizing personal testimonies and archival sources, one can reveal the harsh realities faced by individuals under oppressive regimes, filling in the gaps left by traditional historical narratives. This approach highlights the human capacity for resilience and moral choice, even in the most dire circumstances imposed by national socialist and communist dictatorships.
Methodological Challenges in Historical Research
Researching dictatorships poses unique methodological challenges, particularly when relying on oral history and individual testimonies. While some scholars debate the reliability of such accounts, there is value in firsthand narratives gathered shortly after traumatic events, as they can offer profound insights into the lived experiences of victims. The conversation emphasizes balancing archival research with personal accounts to construct a fuller picture of historical events, revealing the complex interplay between individual actions and the broader systemic forces at work. This dual focus helps historians capture the nuances of human agency amidst the brutality of totalitarian regimes.
The Perpetrators and the Ideology of Dictatorships
A critical examination of the ideological underpinnings of both Nazi and communist regimes reveals how these systems constructed enemies and rationalized violence against them. The discussion illustrates that the logic of extermination and control was deeply rooted in the ideologies of both regimes, which categorized individuals as either part of the national community or as enemies to be eliminated. Each group's designation endured across generations, emphasizing how such ideologies shaped everyday life and morality. This deep-rooted perception of the 'other' facilitated atrocities, as individuals were often dehumanized and stripped of their identity based on arbitrary classifications.
The Long-lasting Impact of Totalitarian Regimes
Dictatorships leave an indelible mark on societies, creating a legacy of fear and trauma that persists across generations. Individuals who lived under such regimes often develop a pervasive sense of paranoia that can influence their interactions and societal dynamics long after the regime has fallen. This previously unexamined aspect of social capital highlights how these collective traumas hinder societies from moving forward or healing. The generational transmission of fear and trauma illustrates the importance of understanding the lasting psychological repercussions of totalitarian rule, which can manifest in personal and social behaviors for decades to come.
A complex array of individual responses to the abuse of power by the state is represented in this book in three horrific episodes in the history of East-Central Europe. The three events followed each other within a span of about ten years: the deportation and murder of Hungarian Jews in Nazi death and labor camps; the Arrow Cross terrorist rule in Budapest; and finally the Stalinist terror in Hungary and East-Central Europe. In Survival under Dictatorships: Life and Death in Nazi and Communist Regimes (Central European UP, 2024), László Borhi explores the relationship between the individual and power, attempting to understand the mechanism of oppression and terror produced by arbitrary, unbridled power through the experience of normal people.
Despite the obvious peculiarities of time and place, the Hungarian cases convey universal lessons about the Holocaust, Nazism, and Stalinism. In the author's conception, the National Socialist and Stalinist experiences are linked on several levels. Both regimes defended their visions of the future against social groups whom they saw as implacable enemies of those visions, and who therefore had to be destroyed for sake of social perfection. Furthermore, the social practices of National Socialism were passed on. And although Stalinism was imposed by a foreign power, some of the survival skills for coping with it were rehearsed under the previous hellish experience.