My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark MFM Minisode 448
Aug 11, 2025
This week features intriguing tales from hometowns, including a wolf in sheep's clothing and a chilling Jeffrey Epstein encounter. A listener shares a haunting childhood secret involving a hidden corpse, unraveling dark family histories with humor. Childhood nostalgia is reflected in a funny car repair mix-up, highlighting camaraderie from the past. The hosts also discuss pet names amidst a shocking tale linked to Epstein. Lastly, laughter arises from amusing grocery store encounters, showcasing youthful determination and quirky challenges.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Hidden Corpse In Neighbor's Attic
- Elle recounts her granny's upstairs neighbor, Lee, hid her husband's chemically mummified body in the attic for 18 years.
- Karen Kilgariff reads details about the ceramic frog, 50 layers of wrapping, and the garden discovery after Lee's death.
Youth Pastor Paid College Students
- Em remembers a youth pastor who ate wings messily, a memory later tied to rumors he paid college women for sex.
- Georgia Hardstark and Karen describe his firing and the town flasher stopping after he left town.
Two Tonys, One Garage
- Karis's mother accidentally went to the wrong Tony's house and waited four hours while the imposter Tony welcomed them.
- The imposter still offered to fix their car and the family later laughed about the 90s phone-book mix-up.