David Crowther, creator of the History of England podcast, digs into the Puritan disdain for Christmas celebrations and Oliver Cromwell's role in that narrative. He discusses how Christmas transformed into a grand festival in England, highlighting unique cultural practices. The conversation also touches on the blend of pagan traditions and societal norms, regional English dishes, and the misconstrued images of Roundheads and Cavaliers during the Civil War. Crowther's insights reveal the complexities of leadership and cultural shifts in historical contexts.
The transformation of Christmas from a minor observance to a prominent holiday highlights the cultural shifts occurring in 16th-century England.
The Puritan opposition to festive celebrations, rooted in their strict religious beliefs, underscores the complex sociopolitical dynamics of 17th-century England.
Deep dives
The Evolution of Christmas in England
Christmas significantly evolved in England from a minor observance in the medieval period to a major holiday by the time of Henry VIII. Initially, Easter was the primary celebration, but starting in the 15th century, Christmas gained prominence with features like the Lord of Misrule, a figure who would preside over festive activities and allow for social inversion. During this season, the festivities included eating, drinking, and merriment, providing a much-needed break from the harsh realities of peasant life. However, this joyful period always faced challenges and criticism from various factions, particularly the Puritans, who opposed the excesses associated with these celebrations.
Puritans and the War on Christmas
The Puritans played a crucial role in the 17th-century push against Christmas celebrations, largely due to their belief that such festivities were rooted in paganism rather than Biblical scripture. They viewed the revelry as disorderly and opposed to their strict religious beliefs, which led to attempts to cancel Christmas altogether during the English Civil War. This ideologically driven hostility towards the holiday was not solely aimed at Christmas but stemmed from a broader disdain for any form of celebration that deviated from their austere lifestyle. Despite these efforts, the stigma around Puritans as the ultimate 'killjoys' oversimplifies the nuanced sociopolitical dynamics of the time.
Understanding Oliver Cromwell's Role
Oliver Cromwell, a prominent figure associated with the Puritan movement, often becomes a focal point in discussions about the suppression of Christmas and festive celebrations. While Cromwell supported policies that dismissed such celebrations as unruly, it is important to note that he did not single-handedly initiate the war on Christmas; rather, it was a collective Puritan effort arising from existing tensions. His personal beliefs showcased a contradiction, where he was seen as a religious pluralist who accepted various forms of worship, yet was part of a movement that sought to diminish public festivities. Cromwell's complex legacy illustrates how political and religious motivations intersected during this turbulent period in England's history.
In a special yuletide episode, Quillette podcast host Jonathan Kay speaks with David Crowther about seventeenth-century puritan attitudes toward yuletide debauchery—and about his acclaimed History of England podcast.