In this discussion, Sarah Burke, Economist Bureau Chief for Mexico, Central America, and the Caribbean, delves into El Salvador’s dramatic shift from gang violence to a crackdown by President Bukele. While the streets are safer, democracy faces grave threats. Burke highlights the plight of families affected by mass detentions and the chilling socio-economic impact on communities. The conversation unveils how Bukele's authoritarian tactics might influence neighboring countries, drawing a complex portrait of resilience amid oppression.
President Nayib Bukele's tough crackdown on gangs in El Salvador has improved safety and reduced violence, but at the cost of eroding democracy and undermining principles of justice.
The success of Bukele's policies in reducing violence and extortion has sparked interest in other countries, but the significant challenges and consequences, including human rights violations and the potential strengthening of gangs, must also be considered.
Deep dives
Shift in Balance of Fear and Safety
The podcast discusses how the balance of fear and safety in a community in El Salvador has shifted over time. Previously, the community was under the control of rival gangs, leading to a high level of violence and restrictions on daily life. However, with the current president, Nayib Bukele, in power, the situation has improved, and people can now walk around with relative safety, start businesses, and socialize. This shift, however, came at the cost of eroding democracy and undermining principles of justice.
Bukele's Crackdown on Gangs
Nayib Bukele, the president of El Salvador, has implemented a tough crackdown on gangs in his country. He made a pact with the gangs initially to reduce violence, but later the pact fell apart, resulting in increased violence and a higher homicide rate. In response, Bukele declared a state of exception, suspending constitutional protections and detaining thousands of people. The government has posted videos and photos on social media showcasing the harsh conditions of prisons to send a message of deterrence. The crackdown has led to a decrease in violence and extortion, but it's raised concerns about human rights violations and the erosion of democracy.
Challenges and Implications
While Bukele's crackdown on gangs has improved the quality of life for many in El Salvador, it has also come with significant challenges and consequences. Families of those detained have borne the burden, struggling to provide supplies and support to their loved ones. The justice system has been overwhelmed, with no convictions or declarations of innocence for the detained individuals. The crackdown has also raised concerns about the long-term impact, as incarceration can strengthen gangs and the root causes of the problem remain unaddressed. The model of Bukele's policies has sparked interest in other countries in the region, but the erosion of democracy and potential for human rights violations are significant drawbacks.
A country that was not long ago gripped by gang violence and crime is slowly emerging from fear, thanks to a brutal roundup of young men by a wildly popular, social-media-savvy president. The streets may be safer, but now it is El Salvador’s democracy that is in danger—and neighbouring countries’ leaders may take lessons from its budding autocrat.
For full access to print, digital and audio editions of The Economist, try a free 30-day digital subscription by going to www.economist.com/intelligenceoffer