Breaking Down the Open Banking Rules with Matt Janiga
Nov 30, 2023
auto_awesome
Former Fintech Layer Cake co-host and regulatory expert Matt Janiga discusses open banking and the potential impacts of the proposed rules. Topics covered include competition, data access, and consumer choice, as well as the influence of major banks and trade groups. The podcast also explores the concept of open banking, the challenges faced by traditional banks, and the rise of fintech applications. It discusses the implications of the rule on screen scraping, the rationale and limitations of open banking rules, and the potential effects on competition in the banking industry. The speaker also highlights Tressley's focus on payments and their ability to help merchants save on interchange costs and offer fraud and risk protections.
The proposed open banking rules may entrench big players in the industry, limiting competition and innovation.
Clear rules and guidance are needed for key components of the 1033 proposal to balance consumer protection and enable competition.
The 1033 proposal raises questions about both potential unintended consequences and new opportunities in the open banking market.
Deep dives
Potential Impact on Competition
The podcast episode discusses the potential impact of the 1033 proposal on competition in the banking industry. The guest argues that if the rules are finalized as they are currently set up, it will entrench the biggest players in the industry and limit the ability of smaller players to compete and offer innovative services. The guest raises concerns about potential decreased innovation and a consolidation of banks due to the regulation, as well as the influence of lobbying by large banks on the final rule.
Key Components of the Proposal
The episode delves into the key components of the 1033 proposal. These components include the consumers' right to share their banking data with innovative companies, the establishment of rules and guardrails for data sharing, restrictions on data use and reuse, limitations on data authorizations, and provisions for account switching. The guest highlights the need for clear rules and guidance on these topics and discusses potential difficulties in balancing consumer protection and enabling competition.
Unintended Consequences and Potential New Product Avenues
The podcast episode explores potential unintended consequences of the 1033 proposal and discusses whether it may open up new product avenues. The guest expresses concern that the proposal may inadvertently result in the entrenchment of existing bigger players and a shrinking of the open banking market. However, there is also discussion of potential new opportunities, such as the opening up of identity data on bank accounts and the possibility of account switching tools. Overall, the episode raises questions about the potential for the proposal to drive innovation and the need for ongoing adjustments and rulemaking to achieve the desired goals.
Policy goals of the proposal
The podcast discusses the policy goals outlined by the Bureau, which include enabling cash flow underwriting and encouraging competition in payments. The goal of cash flow underwriting is to reduce reliance on credit bureaus and allow for more diversified underwriting methods. It is aimed at opening up opportunities for underbanked individuals and increasing competition in the lending market. The proposal also focuses on payment facilitation, aiming to promote competition among payment providers and reduce dependence on traditional card-based payments. The Bureau hopes that by implementing open banking and data sharing, innovative payment solutions can emerge and offer more options to consumers.
Screen scraping and its implications
The podcast delves into the topic of screen scraping and its implications in the 1033 conversation. The proposal allows banks to block screen scraping once they have a compliant API available for consumers. However, it does not outright ban screen scraping, recognizing that there are certain use cases where it is still necessary. The discussion highlights that screen scraping remains essential for accessing data from accounts that fall outside the scope of the proposal, such as captive lender auto loans or retirement accounts. The podcast also touches on the potential challenges in preventing data loss and maintaining service continuity if sweeping revocations are implemented, particularly in recurring payment use cases. Compliance with revocation requirements both at the bank and merchant side is crucial to ensure seamless data access.
Join host Reggie Young in this episode as he explores open banking insights with Matt Janiga, former Fintech Layer Cake co-host, regulatory expert, and current Legal Counsel at Trustly. Dive into the world of open banking and explore the regulatory landscape, dissecting the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's (CFPB) proposed rules. Discover the potential impact on competition, data access, and consumer choice in the fintech ecosystem. Whether you're interested in open banking regulations or cutting-edge payment solutions, this episode offers valuable insights into the fintech industry's evolving landscape.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode