The Constant: A History of Getting Things Wrong The Mysterious Stranger
Jul 1, 2025
Discover the intriguing origins of a tranquil village in New Brunswick and the gripping saga of Henry Moore Smith, accused of horse theft. Follow his tumultuous journey, filled with legal woes and a dramatic disappearance. Unravel the legend surrounding Henry, explore his uncanny escape artistry, and question the truths behind his life. The podcast invites you to enjoy a story rich in mystery, crime, and the exploration of narrative incompleteness.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Horse Theft That Sparked The Mystery
- Wills Frederick Knox chased and captured a man who called himself Henry Moore Smith for stealing his horse and money.
- Smith arrived injured and claimed he'd been beaten and tricked, setting off the long local saga.
The Disappearing Prisoner
- In jail Smith rapidly worsened with coughing, vomiting blood, and fever while Bates and others tended him but could not get him moved to better care.
- Days later, after asking for a heated brick, Smith vanished from his cell with all his possessions missing.
Plain Reporting Bolsters Credibility
- Walter Bates wrote a plain, documentary account that reads credible because of its dryness and verifiable details.
- His style and reputation make the story feel like sincere record-keeping rather than sensational invention.
