Josh Hartnett, known for his pitch-perfect performances in various films, joins the hosts to dissect M. Night Shyamalan's chaotic film, 'Trap.' They analyze the film's third act that falls flat while celebrating Hartnett's standout role and a nearly redemptive shirtless scene. The discussion delves into the complexities of film critique, parental themes, and how humor interplays with emotional depth. They also touch on the evolving nature of film narratives and nostalgia for cinematic experiences shared with friends.
The hosts highlight Josh Hartnett's engaging performance as pivotal, providing humor that momentarily elevates the chaotic narrative of 'Trap'.
They critique M. Night Shyamalan's muddled storytelling, pointing out the film's overly long runtime filled with unnecessary subplots and tonal inconsistencies.
The discussion emphasizes the missed opportunity for deeper emotional exploration of the father-daughter relationship amidst the absurdity of the plot.
Deep dives
Introduction to the Episode Theme
The hosts discuss a movie entitled 'Trap,' starring Josh Hartnett. They reflect on their shared viewing experience, highlighting both the chaos of watching alongside each other and their individual reactions to the film. Kat recalls feeling a mix of confusion and amusement during the cinematic journey, while Jocelyn shares that their viewing was filled with unexpected highs and lows. Their dynamic sets the stage for a critical exploration of the film's strengths and weaknesses.
M. Night Shyamalan's Directing Style
The hosts express their confusion regarding M. Night Shyamalan’s filmmaking approach, comparing 'Trap' to his other works. They note that while the premise initially promises excitement, it quickly devolves into absurdities that leave the audience questioning the narrative's plausibility. Both agree that Shyamalan's writing often exhibits a lack of editing, resulting in an overly long runtime filled with unnecessary subplots. Despite this, they acknowledge that Josh Hartnett's performance provides moments of genuine humor and authenticity, making the film somewhat enjoyable.
Tone and Character Dynamics
Throughout the discussion, the characters are evaluated concerning the film's overall tone, described as a blend of earnestness and camp. The hosts argue that the inherent silliness of the plot could have benefitted from sharper character portrayals, especially in how they relate to one another. They highlight Josh Hartnett's character, Cooper, who navigates his dual roles as a father and a serial killer, ultimately leading to entertaining yet conflicting emotions. This tonal inconsistency leaves the audience challenged to fully invest in the characters amid the chaos of the plot.
Exploration of Major Themes
The podcast delves into the film's exploration of the father-daughter relationship, as Cooper attempts to balance his criminal activities with his desire to be a good parent. While the stakes are set high with an intense backdrop, the hosts feel that the execution falls flat, especially as the narrative shifts gears after leaving the concert venue. Jocelyn and Kat discuss missed opportunities to examine the emotional depth of the characters and their connections, ultimately undermining the film's potential. They suggest that a more thorough examination of the psychological implications would've lent the film a more compelling direction.
Concluding Thoughts on 'Trap'
The hosts wrap up their discussion by acknowledging 'Trap' as a curious mix of entertainment and frustration. They ultimately agree that while Hartnett shines in his role, the film as a whole suffers from poor pacing, an unfocused script, and a failure to deliver on its initial promise. The chemistry and wit between the characters offer brief respite, but it does not save the narrative from its numerous shortcomings. They recommend watching the film for its moments of absurdity but caution viewers regarding its aimless progression.
Head down to the SkyDome in Toronto and hide all evidence of your grisly crimes cause we're talking about Shyalaman's TRAP! We discuss a third act that doesn't work, a PITCH perfect performance by Josh Hartnett, and a shirtless scene that nearly saves the movie. Produced by Andrew Ivimey as part of The From Superheroes Network Visit www.FromSuperheroes.com for more podcasts, articles, video series, web comics, and more.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode