Noam Leshem, "Edges of Care: Living and Dying in No Man's Land" (U Chicago Press, 2025)
Mar 1, 2025
auto_awesome
Noam Leshem, author of "Edges of Care: Living and Dying in No Man's Land," explores the realities of abandoned spaces across the globe. He discusses the concept of 'no man’s land' in conflict zones, revealing how these areas, often deemed forgotten, are full of life and resilience. From the struggles of Sheikh Saad during the pandemic to Gaza's complex landscape under blockade, Leshem sheds light on the political ramifications of such abandonment and calls for a deeper understanding of care in these communities.
No man's land is redefined as spaces of radical abandonment, showcasing how communities persist and sometimes thrive without state support.
The author emphasizes personal experiences of living in no man's land, reflecting on how such spaces shape individual identities and societal relationships.
Deep dives
Understanding No Man's Land
The concept of no man's land is explored as a space of radical abandonment by the state, reflecting a lack of sovereign care toward both land and its inhabitants. This notion extends beyond familiar historical contexts, like the World War I trenches, to contemporary locations where communities exist without oversight or support from governing bodies. Through extensive research in conflict zones, the author reveals that these areas can still thrive despite neglect, showcasing resilience and new forms of existence that emerge in such abandoned places. By broadening the definition of no man's land to include various geographic and social landscapes, the discussion emphasizes how these spaces challenge traditional political theories and reveal urgent issues of care and responsibility.
Personal Reflections on Identity
The author's personal background informs their exploration of no man's land, revealing how these themes resonate on an individual level. Growing up in a community classified as no man's land between Israel and Jordan, the author reflects on how early exposure to concepts of abandonment shaped their understanding of identity and belonging. This lived experience illustrates the emotional and societal ramifications of existing in liminal spaces marked by conflict and instability. Through these reflections, the text invites readers to consider how historical and political narratives are tied to personal identities, urging a deeper engagement with the histories that shape different communities.
The Dual Nature of Governance in Gaza
The situation in Gaza is presented as a stark contrast to traditional no man's land, characterized by a regime of effective control and pervasive neglect. The Israeli blockade exemplifies a form of invasive governance that profoundly affects the day-to-day lives of Gazans, demonstrating how abandonment can occur even amidst strict oversight. This dichotomy of control versus care highlights the complexities of state responsibilities, as the sovereign presence can lead to both protection and oppression. By analyzing Gaza's unique situation, the text encourages readers to rethink notions of sovereignty, care, and the conditions surrounding marginalized populations.
Imagining New Futures in Abandoned Spaces
No man's land serves as a canvas for radical experimentation and creativity, where marginalized communities can forge new identities and connections. The author celebrates the example of Musrara, a neighborhood that transitioned from a site of conflict to a space fostering cultural exchange between Jewish and Palestinian residents after the 1967 war. This intersectionality cultivates a rich environment for collaboration and innovation, challenging the conventional narratives surrounding conflict zones. By focusing on the potential for regeneration in these abandoned spaces, the author advocates for recognizing the possibilities inherent in places often perceived as voids or desolation.
“No man’s land” invokes stretches of barren landscape, twisted barbed wire, desolation, and the devastation of war. But this is not always the reality. According to Noam Leshem in Edges of Care: Living and Dying in No Man's Land(U Chicago Press, 2025), the term also reveals radical abandonment by the state. From the Northern Sahara to the Amazon rainforests, people around the world find themselves in places that have been stripped of sovereign care. Leshem is committed to defining these spaces and providing a more intimate understanding of this urgent political reality.
Based on nearly a decade of research in some of the world’s most challenging conflict zones, Edges of Care offers a profound account of abandoned lives and lands, and how they endure and sometimes thrive once left to fend for themselves. Leshem interrogates no man’s land as a site of radical uncaring: abandoned by a sovereign power in a relinquishment of responsibility for the space or anyone inside it. To understand the ramifications of such uncaring, Leshem takes readers through a diverse series of abandoned places, including areas in Palestine, Syria, Colombia, Sudan, and Cyprus. He shows that no man’s land is not empty of life, but almost always inhabited and, in fact, often generative of new modes of being.
Roberto Mazza is currently a visiting scholar at the Buffett Institute for Global Affairs at Northwestern University. He is the host of the Jerusalem Unplugged Podcast and to discuss and propose a book for interview can be reached at robbymazza@gmail.com. Blusky and IG: @robbyref Website: www.robertomazza.org