Crain & Company AP POLL REACTION & College Football Week 12 Recap | Alabama Falls Far
Nov 16, 2025
The hosts dive into the latest College Football AP Poll, sparking debate over Alabama's surprising drop and Texas's ranking. They analyze the playoff implications for various teams, including the Big 12 and the Iron Bowl's impact on Alabama's season. Highlights include Texas A&M's thrilling comeback against South Carolina and USC's strong performance against Iowa. The discussion also covers Michigan's narrow win, Ohio State's dominance, and Notre Dame's defensive prowess. They wrap up with insights into upcoming matchups and playoff scenarios.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
AP Polls Are Inconsistent And Unreliable
- AP voters show inconsistent logic, producing odd rankings like Alabama falling to 10th despite resume.
- This unpredictability means AP order doesn't reliably predict playoff committee decisions.
Recency And Narrative Drive Voter Movement
- Voters reward Notre Dame's win streak and recent high-profile performances over head-to-head parity.
- That creates odd separations where similar two-loss teams rank differently based on timing and narrative.
Win The Conference To Improve Playoff Odds
- If two Big 12 teams enter the title game 11-1, expect the committee to likely pick only the champion.
- Prioritize winning the conference title to secure the best playoff chance.