In this intriguing conversation, former President Donald Trump, known for his polarizing legal journey, discusses his extensive history of over 3,500 lawsuits. Trump explains how he wields litigation as a tool for brand and political power. Award-winning journalist Andrea Bernstein explores his strategic legal tactics since leaving office, detailing key cases and the impact on public perception. The episode also dives into the influence of his lawyer Roy Cohn on Trump's approach to law and litigation, shaping his ambitions and controversies.
Donald Trump's extensive litigation history, exceeding 3,500 lawsuits, demonstrates his strategic use of legal battles to manipulate public perception and assert dominance.
The influence of Roy Cohn on Trump's legal strategies underscores a departure from traditional practices, favoring aggressive tactics and public confrontation over settlement.
Deep dives
Trump's Legal History and Its Impact
Donald Trump's extensive legal history includes over 3,500 lawsuits, reflecting a pattern of using the court system to manipulate public perception and advance his interests. Many of these cases have been against business associates and media figures, showcasing his tendency to initiate lawsuits as a tool for intimidation. Notably, Trump has faced a number of serious indictments and civil liabilities, including significant financial judgments against him for fraud and defamation. This litigious behavior not only illustrates his personal approach to disputes but also sets a precedent for his supporters regarding how to engage with legal systems.
Litigation as a Weapon
Post-presidency, Trump has continued to engage in a series of lawsuits, reinforcing his narrative of persecution while simultaneously targeting political rivals. For instance, his lawsuits against figures like Hillary Clinton and various media personalities reveal his strategy of utilizing litigation as a means of asserting power and dominance. Many of these lawsuits, including a defamation claim, were deemed frivolous, resulting in sanctions against Trump, yet this has not deterred him from pursuing similar tactics. This ongoing legal aggression serves to intimidate opponents and bolster Trump's political brand, turning courtroom battles into platforms for his grievances.
Influence of Roy Cohn
Central to understanding Trump's approach to litigation is his relationship with Roy Cohn, a controversial lawyer who guided Trump through various legal challenges early in his career. Cohn's strategy emphasized aggression in legal matters, advising Trump to fight accusations rather than seek settlements, which shaped Trump's perspective on handling disputes. This dynamic showcases a shift from traditional legal practices to a more combative, politically charged approach to justice and media relations. The techniques learned from Cohn, such as publicizing lawsuits to exert pressure, remain evident in Trump's current legal maneuvering.
Contesting Judicial Authority
Trump's disregard for judicial norms raises concerns about the integrity of the legal system, as demonstrated by his persistent claim of being victimized by lawfare. This narrative serves not only to energize his base but also to manipulate public opinion against judicial authority and accountability. His recent legal battles, including challenges arising from his presidency, illustrate a deliberate effort to blur the lines between legitimate legal strategy and the abuse of the judicial process. By framing civil litigation as part of a broader political battle, Trump effectively transforms his personal grievances into a rallying cry for his supporters, undermining trust in the courts.
In the first in a new series, The Law According to Trump, Amicus begins an extensive exploration of Donald Trump's tumultuous relationship with the courts and legal system, focusing on Trump's use of lawyers and lawsuits to enhance his brand, wealth, and power. In the past few months, attention has rightly been on several blockbuster federal cases involving former President Trump, all the way up to and including his immunity case at the Supreme Court, but Trump’s history with the law goes back much further and is much broader than the election subversion cases.
This episode delves into Trump's history of litigation with a close eye on how he has used nuisance lawsuits. Slate’s jurisprudence editor Jeremy Stahl joins Andrea to outline the many people and organizations the former President has sued since leaving office. Then, former US Attorney Jim Zirin, author of Plaintiff in Chief: A Portrait of Donald Trump in 3500 Lawsuits, fills us in on the history of Trump’s love of litigation.
Want more Amicus? Subscribe to Slate Plus to immediately unlock exclusive SCOTUS analysis and weekly extended episodes. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Or, visit slate.com/amicusplus to get access wherever you listen.