Bryan Ward-Perkins: The material consequences of the fall of Rome
Aug 2, 2024
auto_awesome
Bryan Ward-Perkins, an archaeologist and historian focused on economic history, discusses his work on the material consequences of Rome's collapse. He challenges the notion that Rome fell into a slow decline, presenting it as a transformative process marked by evidence of economic downfall and cultural shifts. Topics include the loss of advanced construction skills, the emergence of new trading towns, and the contrasting experiences of the Western and Eastern Empires. Ward-Perkins also explores the role of lead pipes and migration in this pivotal historical moment.
Ward-Perkins argues that the fall of the Roman Empire brought a significant decline in material culture and economic complexity.
The podcast emphasizes the importance of archaeological evidence to understand the societal and economic shifts post-Rome's collapse.
Ward-Perkins draws parallels between the fragility of the Roman economy and modern societies' reliance on complex supply chains.
Deep dives
Understanding Genetic Risk in Embryos
Embryos show a significant variation in genetic predisposition to severe diseases, with estimates indicating a 30 to 60% difference. This means that, even if parents are healthy, their embryo could carry mutations that pose severe health risks. The use of genetic calculators allows parents to evaluate the potential impact of selecting embryos with lower genetic risks. This technology represents a notable advancement in embryo screening and in vitro fertilization (IVF) processes, enhancing parental decision-making.
Revisiting the Fall of the Roman Empire
Dr. Brian Ward-Perkins challenges the notion that the fall of the Roman Empire wasn't as catastrophic as often claimed, arguing for a narrative of significant decline rather than gradual transformation. He points to archaeological evidence that indicates dramatic shifts in material culture and economy during the 5th to 7th centuries. The decline in the production of everyday goods, such as pottery and nails, highlights a clear regression from the Roman period's complexity. This shift illustrates the broader implications of political and military changes on daily life and economic stability.
Material Culture and Economic Disintegration
Ward-Perkins highlights the stark contrast between the Roman Empire's advanced economic systems and those of the post-Roman period. Items such as pottery and bricks exemplify the substantial loss of manufacturing expertise following the Empire's collapse. The clear decline in specialized production points to a disintegration of complex supply chains essential for sustaining consumer goods. This regression suggests that life after the Roman Empire lacked the material comfort and technological advancements enjoyed by its citizens.
Methodological Differences in Historical Perspectives
The contrasting viewpoints of historians often originate from different methodological approaches, with political histories focusing on events rather than material culture. Ward-Perkins emphasizes the importance of archaeological evidence in understanding the dramatic shifts in societal structure following the fall of Rome. His analyses of physical artifacts compel a reconsideration of how historians interpret this period. By prioritizing material culture, he opens up discussions about economic disintegration and social transformation.
The Fragility of Complex Economies
Ward-Perkins warns about the fragility of complex societies, emphasizing how a sophisticated economy can unravel into simpler forms when faced with disruptions. He draws parallels between the fall of the Roman economic framework and contemporary society’s reliance on intricate supply chains. The consequences of such disintegration can lead to lasting impacts on technological advancement and quality of life. This perspective urges reflection on the resilience of modern economies amidst potential vulnerabilities in global systems.
On this episode of Unsupervised Learning Razib talks to archeologist and historian Bryan Ward-Perkins about his 2005 book The Fall of Rome: And the End of Civilization. Ward-Perkins was born and grew up in Rome, a son of architectural historian and archaeologist, John Bryan Ward-Perkins. Educated at Oxford University, Ward-Perkins eventually became a fellow of Trinity College at the same university, from which he has since retired. An archaeologist with a deep interest in economic history, Ward-Perkins’ standout book The Fall of Rome was to a great extent a restatement of traditional understandings of the Roman fall in the wake of academic revisions stimulated by Peter Brown’s 1989 World of Late Antiquity: AD 150-750. Ward-Perkins scholarship focuses on the outputs of economic production: fine pottery, grand public buildings and copious coinage. In contrast, Brown and his fellow travelers tended to focus on religious innovation and creativity in the centuries coincident with Rome's fall. The Fall of Rome documents in crisp, dense prose the material collapse attendant with the dissolution of the Western Empire in the late 5th and 6th centuries, from the vanishing of pottery in Britain to the cessation of the construction of massive buildings across the Italian peninsula.
Razib also asks Ward-Perkins his opinions on his colleague Pete Heather’s book The Fall of the Roman Empire: A New History of Rome and the Barbarians. Ward-Perkins sees Heather’s work as complementary; while Ward-Perkins is interested in the material aspects of everyday Roman life, Heather documents and narrates the diplomatic and military affairs of the Roman elite. Ward-Perkins also comments on Chris Wickham’s work in books likeThe Inheritance of Rome: Illuminating the Dark Ages 400-1000, which outlines how the Roman and post-Roman states differed, in particular, the disappearance in Europe of professional soldiers paid in currency, rather than feudal levies. They also discuss Walter Scheidel’s Escape from Rome: The Failure of Empire and the Road to Prosperity, and whether Roman citizens were actually materially better off than their medieval successors. Ward-Perkins also gives his estimation of the time measured in centuries until Western Europe reattained Roman levels of social, technological and political complexity.