In this episode, Richard Reinsch, Editor in Chief of the Civitas Outlook at the University of Texas, delves into the reimagining of conservatism. He discusses the importance of reforming institutions from within, especially in the face of progressive ideologies in higher education. The conversation explores the historical context of conservative thought, the impact of electoral outcomes, the nature of politics and free speech, and the pressing need to balance idealism and realism for the future of the Republican party.
Conservatives should focus on reforming established institutions instead of creating parallel structures to effectively influence political discourse.
The evolving nature of conservatism reveals a tension between traditional values and emerging populist trends that must be addressed for future unity.
State universities play a crucial role in conservative dialogue, necessitating the establishment of alternative perspectives to challenge dominant progressive ideologies.
Deep dives
The Importance of Engaging Existing Institutions
The conversation highlights the need for conservatives to focus on reclaiming existing institutions rather than creating parallel structures. Richard Reinsch emphasizes the effectiveness of embedding conservative viewpoints within established universities and think tanks to foster meaningful dialogue. He points to the Civitas Institute at the University of Texas as an example of this approach, aiming to redefine the American consensus around economic growth and constitutional government. By actively participating in these institutions, conservatives can influence discourse and navigate the complexities of contemporary debates more effectively.
Understanding the Changing Landscape of Conservatism
The discussion delves into the shifting nature of conservatism, acknowledging the divide between traditional conservatism and the emerging populist movements within the party. Reinsch notes the evolution of the conservative base, highlighting that extreme positions on the right now echo some illiberal tendencies typically associated with the left. This convergence raises questions about the future of conservatism, with a need to reassess foundational principles that emphasize limited government and individual freedoms. The conversation challenges listeners to reflect on what conservatism ultimately aims to conserve in the face of these changing dynamics.
The Role of Higher Education in Shaping Political Discourse
The podcast outlines the crucial role that state universities play in the broader context of political dialogue, especially in conservative circles. Reinsch points out that many conservatives are recognizing the impact of progressive ideologies on college campuses, leading to a demand for alternative perspectives. The mission of centers like the Civitas Institute is to create spaces for constructive debate and provide diverse viewpoints that challenge the prevailing narratives. By interacting with students and faculty, these institutes can influence the ideological landscape of higher education.
Rethinking Political Mandates and Governance
The discussion raises significant questions about the concept of political mandates, particularly in the context of Trump’s presidency. Reinsch posits that the notion of a mandate is often misconstrued within modern politics, with a focus on ideological victories rather than the underlying principles of governance. This misunderstanding reflects a departure from constitutional values that necessitate compromise and deliberation. By examining historical perspectives on governance, the conversation underscores the importance of viewing elections as opportunities for dialogue rather than mere declarations of victory.
The Future of Conservatism: Fusion or Division?
The conversation ultimately grapples with the question of conservatism's future direction, debating whether it will revert to a fusionist project or become increasingly fragmented. Reinsch advocates for a reinvigoration of the constitutional tradition as a unifying force within conservatism, emphasizing the need for cohesive principles that transcend current ideological debates. By grounding conservatism in a robust understanding of American constitutionalism, there lies potential for fostering broader electoral coalitions. The challenge remains whether conservatives can effectively adapt and align their approaches to resonate with a diverse electorate while remaining true to their core values.
Once again, Jonah Goldberg has received countless requests from the children of the world for some serious conservative eggheadery for Christmas. Ever benevolent, Jonah has obliged by hosting Richard Reinsch, the Editor in Chief of the Civitas Outlook at the University of Texas to discuss how conservatives can reform existing institutions from the inside out. Jonah and Richard also cover the legitimacy of Trump’s perceived mandate, the merits of competitive federalism, the storied history of conservative doomcasting, and the future of the Republican party.
The Remnant is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including Jonah’s G-File newsletter, weekly livestreams, and other members-only content—click here.
