Trump Edition: Annexing Canada, negotiating with Russia and containing China
Mar 14, 2025
auto_awesome
In this insightful discussion, Memphis Barker, a Telegraph foreign correspondent in Alberta, explores the separatist sentiments in Canada and the controversial idea of annexation, revealing surprising opinions from locals. Tom Wright, a strategic advisor in the Biden White House, offers a deep dive into U.S. relations with Russia and China. The conversation addresses national security concerns, emotional ties to independence in Alberta, and the complicated diplomacy surrounding the Ukraine conflict, all while examining the currents of U.S. foreign policy under both Trump and Biden.
Trump's suggestion to annex Canada has ignited strong opposition among Canadians, unifying them around the idea of protecting their sovereignty.
Alberta's desire to join the U.S. reflects a broader sentiment of economic exploitation and political marginalization from the Canadian federal government.
Deep dives
Canada as a Potential 51st State
Donald Trump has suggested the idea of making Canada the 51st state, initially amusing many but now causing increasing anger among Canadians. The trade war between the U.S. and Canada has intensified, with Canada imposing retaliatory tariffs in response to Trump's actions. Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has accused Trump of attempting to damage the Canadian economy, while polls indicate that the majority of Canadians oppose any form of annexation. This rhetoric has unexpectedly united Canadians in support of their government, showing a strong desire to maintain their sovereignty.
Alberta's Oil Economy and Separatist Sentiment
In Alberta, discussions about joining the U.S. resonate due to a deep-seated resentment towards the federal government, primarily stemming from equalization payments that redistribute oil wealth to other provinces. Alberta is a key oil-producing region, significantly contributing to U.S. oil imports, and many feel that their hard work is exploited while the profits are sent to regions that do not share the same resource abundance. The province’s identity is closely tied to oil, and the frustrations of Alberta's citizens are further fueled by perceived neglect from the liberal government and a lack of infrastructure support. As a result, some Albertans express a desire to align with the U.S. to seek economic freedom and more favorable regulations.
Discontent and Calls for Independence
The separatist sentiment in Alberta is mirrored by sentiments in other resource-rich regions globally, where residents feel economically exploited and politically marginalized. Many in Alberta harbor feelings of being looked down upon by the Canadian federal government, particularly regarding policies perceived as favoring populous eastern provinces. This has led to some individuals swearing allegiance to the U.S. as a rejection of what they see as a lack of representation and respect. The desire for independence or union with the U.S. is rooted in a broader sense of regional identity and a push for political autonomy.
Concerns Over National Defense and Military Capability
Concerns about Canada’s military capabilities have been raised by individuals supporting the notion of joining the U.S., particularly in light of perceived threats from Russia and China. Those advocating for annexation argue that Canada lacks the military strength necessary to defend its interests effectively, and that alignment with the U.S. could provide necessary security. This perspective reflects a deepened anxiety regarding Canadian sovereignty and national protection, especially in light of increasing geopolitical tensions. Historical ties and the socio-political landscape of Alberta contribute to the dialogue about American military support and how it could benefit the region.
Donald Trump has long expressed a desire to make Canada the 51st state of the US, with tensions rising as the two countries engage in a trade war. Canada has implemented retaliatory tariffs against Trump’s policies, and outgoing Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has accused Trump of trying to weaken the Canadian economy to make annexation easier. Polling suggests 90% of Canadians say they would oppose becoming part of the US, but not everyone shares that view. Telegraph foreign correspondent Memphis Barker meets with those who believe joining the US might not be such a bad idea.
Plus: Thomas Wright, strategic and national security advisor in the Biden White House, speaks with Roland Oliphant about Trump's approach to Russia and China, and the surprising continuity between the Biden and Trump administrations.
For more context on the issue of Canada, listen to the episode 'Trump edition: The Canadians fighting back against annexation'