Dateline NBC Talking Dateline: Secrets in the Mist
Jun 18, 2025
Join Keith Morrison and Dennis Murphy as they dive into the chilling case of Carol Lubahn, a young mother who vanished under mysterious circumstances. They unravel how innovative detective work, including social media sleuthing, brought her husband Mike to justice. Listen to gripping insights as they discuss Mike's son's emotional struggle between seeking the truth and supporting his father. Plus, Keith reveals his unique storytelling approach, making the case even more compelling!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Creative Cold Case Evidence
- The case against Mike Lubahn hinged more on his inconsistent statements and behavior than physical evidence.
- Facebook absence was used creatively as evidence to suggest Carol was deceased, illustrating modern forensic innovation in cold cases.
Complex Family Dynamics
- Mike was seen as steady and dependable, earning trust by taking over Carol’s father’s painting business.
- Carol was bored, had multiple affairs, and ultimately disappeared, sparking decades-long suspicions.
Power of Story Changes
- Detectives rely heavily on inconsistencies in suspects' stories to detect guilt.
- Incremental changes and contradictions in a timeline often prove more convincing than physical evidence in court.