Caroline Thornham, a dedicated reporter known for her investigative prowess, dives deep into a web of deception with chilling real-life implications. She recounts the story of a shy teenager, Faye, who unwittingly becomes embroiled in an FBI sting operation to fake her own death due to a murder-for-hire plot. Thornham explores the psychological and ethical complexities of undercover operations, shedding light on the emotional toll on victims and the stark realities of navigating love amidst danger.
Faye's journey illustrates the dangers of online relationships, highlighting how emotional attachments can lead to perilous situations in real life.
The FBI's use of a morally complex undercover operation raises significant ethical questions about law enforcement practices in protecting vulnerable victims.
Deep dives
Faye's Encounter with the FBI
A young woman, referred to as Faye, discovers she is the target of a murder-for-hire plot after her local sheriff informs her that someone has paid over $14,000 for her death. Accompanied by her mother, Faye visits the FBI office in Phoenix, Arizona, where agents conduct an intimidating interview regarding her potential assailant. During the questioning, Faye suspects her ex-boyfriend, Scott, due to their tumultuous breakup and his last cryptic message. The FBI agents express their intention to investigate her case thoroughly, leading to an unexpected and dangerous plan.
The Complicated Relationship with Scott
Faye's relationship with Scott began during the pandemic through online interactions, where they developed a deep emotional attachment without meeting in person. When she finally visits him in Beverly Hills, the relationship takes a dark turn, as Scott pressures Faye into an intimate encounter against her will. Faye grapples with the aftermath, and despite her initial feelings of love, she realizes that the experience was exploitative and damaging. After returning home, her discomfort escalates as Scott continues to message her, leading to an eventual breakup.
The FBI's Undercover Operation
Upon learning about the murder plot against Faye, the FBI initiates a complex undercover operation to gather evidence against Scott by posing as a hitman. To convince Scott of their credibility, they require Faye to participate in staged photos that illustrate her 'death' and to show that they are monitoring her, making it a tense situation for her. The plan involves meticulous attention to detail as the agents need to create conditions that convincingly depict Faye's imminent demise to Scott. This unusual approach raises moral questions about the extent to which law enforcement should go in order to protect a victim.
Legal Ramifications and Faye's Healing Journey
After Scott's arrest for orchestrating the murder plot, he attempts to obstruct justice by instructing an inmate to erase evidence to bolster his defense, ultimately leading to his conviction. Scott is sentenced to five years in prison, but Faye feels the punishment is insufficient for the trauma she endured. The case prompts broader discussions about the effectiveness and ethics of FBI tactics in handling similar incidents, emphasizing the need for victim-sensitive practices in law enforcement. As Faye navigates her healing process, she reflects on how the experience will always impact her sense of safety and trust.
When a shy 19 year old from rural Arizona, applies to be the admin of a fan page for her favorite TV show, she has no idea it will lead to the FBI asking her to fake her own death.
Follow the Kill List on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. You can binge all episodes early and ad-free on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting www.wondery.com/links/kill-list now.