Electing Judges: A Controversial Reform

Mexico is set to implement a groundbreaking reform that allows for the direct election of its judges, a move spurred by the government's desire to address widespread corruption in the justice system. Supporters argue that this reform will bring the judiciary closer to the people and could lead to a more accountable legal system. However, critics highlight the potential risks, suggesting that this change could politicize the judiciary and compromise its independence, especially in the context of organized crime's influence on local elections. Evidence from countries like the United States raises concerns that elected judges may be swayed by political pressures and public opinions, undermining the impartiality of the judicial process.