Episode 6: Show Ponies and Paper Tigers with PJ Budler

Episode 6: Show Ponies and Paper Tigers with PJ Budler

In this episode PJ takes us on a global cattle expedition that challenges everything we think we know about breeding. Having judged cattle in 48 countries, Budler offers a rare perspective on the disconnect between American cattle breeding philosophies and what actually works around the world.

Budler introduces two powerful metaphors that perfectly capture the industry's challenges: "show ponies" (cattle bred for ribbons rather than practicality) and "paper tigers" (animals selected solely on spreadsheet data). Both approaches have created genetics that often collapse when exported to different environments – particularly troubling since 80% of the world's cattle live in tropical or subtropical regions where adapted animals are essential.

The conversation takes a fascinating turn when Budler challenges the industry claim that fertility is "lowly heritable," calling out the nutrition companies that benefit from this misconception. "If you had 300 cows and a hundred were Holstein, a hundred Brahman, and a hundred Angus, you know which group would have the highest calf crop before we even start – it's definitely genetic," Budler explains.

Perhaps the most valuable takeaway comes from Budler's counterintuitive approach to selection: breed against negative outliers rather than for positive extremes. "If you're average for just about everything but an outlier in a positive way for fertility, you're profitable," he says, encouraging ranchers to pursue balance over extremes.

PJ concludes with a powerful perspective on cattle producers as "superheroes" who not only feed the population but maintain rural communities and contribute to national security by stewarding vast tracts of land. His message offers hope that by returning to adapted, balanced genetics, ranchers can create sustainable operations that benefit both people and the environment.

Connect with PJ Budler:

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100009980023978

Check out Bos Sires:

Website: https://www.bossires.com/

Bos Sires Catalog: International New Bos Sires Catalog (English)

Support the Podcast

If you enjoy the show and want to support our mission of restoring sustainable, long-lasting genetics to the cattle industry, consider joining our Patreon community. Your support helps us continue producing valuable content for ranchers and cattle enthusiasts worldwide.

Join us on Patreon: [https://www.patreon.com/bossirestalk]