In this engaging discussion, Carol Safir, the Head of the Board of Trustees for the New York City Police Museum, shares insights about the historical significance of the NYPD. Bill Williams, descendant of Clubber Williams, reflects on his ancestor's impact and the complexities of legacy. Leslie Cornfeld sheds light on the NYPD's corruption investigations, highlighting the patterns of scandal and reform over the past century. They delve into the challenge of portraying policing history and the critical need for accountability and transparency in law enforcement.
The historical investigation into the NYPD by the Lexow Committee exposed systemic corruption but resulted in minimal accountability for officers involved.
Carol Safer's perspective from the NYC Police Museum raises ethical concerns about sanitizing police history while promoting a positive image of the force.
Deep dives
The Role of the New York City Police Museum
The New York City Police Museum aims to reshape public perception by highlighting the positive contributions of the police force while downplaying instances of violence and corruption. Carol Safer, the museum's head, emphasizes the importance of fostering reverence for the police rather than fear among the public. She controversially suggests that violent incidents should not be part of the museum narrative, arguing that highlighting a few bad apples overshadows the majority of good officers. This perspective raises concerns about historical accuracy and the potential sanitization of the police's complex legacy.
Historical Context of Corruption in NYPD
The podcast delves deep into the NYPD's historical patterns of corruption, revealing a cyclical nature of scandals that have persisted for over a century. From the sermon of Reverend Charles Henry Parkhurst in 1892, which accused the police of being complicit in organized crime, to modern assessments, the investigation portrays a department riddled with systemic issues. Despite various reforms and public outrage, the narrative suggests that the lack of accountability persists, allowing corruption to thrive within the force. This enduring cycle illustrates the ongoing struggle to achieve significant and lasting reform within the NYPD.
The Lexow Committee Investigation
The Lexow Committee in 1894 represents a pivotal moment in the history of police accountability, as it conducted the first major investigation of the NYPD's extensive corruption. Initially met with skepticism, the investigation gained momentum under the leadership of John Goff, who called various witnesses, including individuals from the underworld, to testify about police misconduct. As shocking testimonies emerged, exposing the deep-seated bribery and extortion within the department, public awareness of the pervasive corruption grew. However, despite the substantial evidence presented, the final report yielded minimal legal repercussions for those implicated, highlighting the challenges in achieving true accountability in law enforcement.
Continuing Impacts of Police Misconduct
The discussion extends to contemporary reflections on police misconduct, drawing parallels between past and present challenges within the NYPD. Documented cases of misconduct and corruption continue to haunt the department, raising questions about its capacity for reform and dedication to public safety. The podcast emphasizes that many historical incidents of police violence and corruption remain unresolved, affecting community trust and safety today. As listeners learn about the ongoing patterns of abuse and the historical context behind them, there is a poignant call to recognize and confront these enduring issues to pave the way for meaningful change.
It’s like clockwork: every 20 years or so, a corruption scandal forces the NYPD into the hot seat. But how did this cycle begin? To find out, we go back over a century ago to the very first investigation into the police where the NYPD is put on trial like never before.
From Wondery, Crooked Media and PushBlack.
Empire City is made with a commitment to ensure the stories of those who were and are still impacted by the NYPD are always part of the stories we tell ourselves about the police, about America, and about democracy.
Follow Empire City: The Untold Origin Story of the NYPD on the Wondery App or wherever you listen to your podcasts. You can binge all episodes early and ad-free on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting wondery.com/links/empire-city/ now.