Tia Levings, a former Christian fundamentalist and survivor of church-sanctioned domestic violence, dives into her experiences with mission trips. She critiques the cult-like nature of these trips, exposing the ethical dilemmas and cultural insensitivity often wrapped in a guise of altruism. Tia humorously narrates a clash between two participants over a romantic interest, reflecting on the absurdities within these environments. Ultimately, she advocates for supporting local initiatives over imposing beliefs, shedding light on the complexities of modern evangelism.
Mission trips often stem from a misguided sense of superiority, masking harmful white saviorism and cultural insensitivity among participants.
Many missionaries experience significant psychological challenges and trauma during trips, highlighting the need for better preparation and support.
Training for mission trips can isolate recruits from outside relationships, resulting in a dangerous indoctrination that suppresses critical thinking.
Deep dives
The Cult of Mission Trips
Mission trips are often framed as altruistic endeavors aimed at helping impoverished communities, particularly in developing countries. However, they frequently involve a deeper motivation of indoctrination and a sense of superiority among participants. Many missionaries, especially young adults, embark on these trips with little understanding of the cultures they are entering, sometimes leading to cultural insensitivity. The justification for these trips is rooted in the belief of 'saving' others, despite the fact that their presence often does more harm than good.
White Savior Complex
A critical issue surrounding mission trips is the phenomenon of white saviorism, where well-meaning volunteers from developed nations engage with communities in ways that can be both exploitative and patronizing. This dynamic is highlighted when volunteers take photos with local children for social media, often without consent, which promotes a harmful narrative. Additionally, many young missionaries lack the skills and training necessary to provide meaningful assistance, leading to instances where they exacerbate existing challenges faced by local communities. The practice is characterized by an infantilizing attitude toward the very people they aim to help.
Training and Isolation in Missions
In some religious organizations, missionary training emphasizes isolation from the broader world, making recruits dependent on church doctrine and authority. This can include an indoctrination process that develops a skewed perception of reality, wherein personal revelations are interpreted as divine guidance. The training often involves canceling personal relationships outside of the church, which creates an insular community focused solely on evangelism. This isolation can lead to a form of mental conditioning that suppresses critical thinking and personal autonomy.
Consumerism and Cultish Experiences
Mission trips can sometimes resemble consumer experiences disguised as benevolent service, where participants pay significant fees to join these trips, akin to purchasing a vacation package. The narrative emphasizes personal transformation for missionaries, overshadowing the actual needs of the local populations. This transactional approach reduces genuine service to a performative act, where the focus shifts from helping others to enhancing one's own spiritual or social experiences. Critics argue that this model commodifies altruism, transforming what should be an act of service into a mere opportunity for youthful adventure.
Psychological Impact and Trauma
Participants in mission trips often face significant psychological challenges stemming from their experiences, including exposure to traumatic circumstances in foreign environments. Instances of cultural misunderstanding and unpreparedness can lead to feelings of inadequacy and exploitation for both the missionaries and local communities. Reports of harmful situations, such as health risks and emotional distress, often go unaddressed within the supportive frameworks of the church. These realities raise concerns about the long-term effects of mission trips on both the volunteers and the communities they aim to serve.
Pack your hammer and your lack of cultural awareness, because this week on Sounds Like A Cult, we're interviewing Tia Levings, a former Christian fundamentalist, mission trip devotee, and survivor of church-sanctioned domestic violence. Tia is also the author of the brand new memoir A Well-Trained Wife. She joins to discuss the ever-so-common culty practice of recruiting church kids to go on white savior vacations all under the guise of bringing Sky Daddy and ultimate nepo kid Jesus into the lives of people who most certainly never asked for that. Aka, mission trips! Many thanks to all the listeners who submitted call-ins for this episode! Be sure to listen to the end, because we’ve got a verrrrrrrry exciting announcement about next season coming :)
To order Amanda's new book, The Age of Magical Overthinking: Notes on Modern Irrationality, click here. To subscribe to Amanda's new Magical Overthinkers podcast and/or watch full episodes on YouTube, click here :)
Head to Squarespace.com for a free trial, and when you’re ready to launch, go to https://www.squarespace.com/CULT to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
Earn points by paying rent right now when you go to joinbilt.com/cult.
Shop the SKIMS Soft Lounge Collection at SKIMS.com. After you place your order, select "Sounds Like A Cult" in the survey and select our show in the dropdown menu that follows.
Go to the App Store or Google Play store and download the FREE Ibotta app to start earning cash back and use code CULT.