Unraveling the Threads of Mormon History w/ Sandra Tanner | Ep. 1978
Dec 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Sandra Tanner, a descendant of Brigham Young and prominent historian, shares her profound insights into the complexities of Mormon polygamy and heritage. She delves into her family history, including the life of Mary Ann Angell, highlighting the emotional struggles of polygamous life. Tanner recounts her journey in historical research with her late husband, Jerald, and reflects on pivotal encounters with notable figures in the faith. Their discussion intertwines personal narratives with significant events like the Mountain Meadows Massacre, fostering a nuanced understanding of belief and legacy.
Sandra Tanner shares her complex family history, revealing the emotional challenges faced by her ancestor Mary Ann Angell in polygamous marriage.
The Mountain Meadows Massacre deeply impacted Tanner's understanding of her lineage, prompting meaningful discussions on historical injustices in her family.
Mentorship from figures like Lamar Peterson invigorated Sandra and Jerald Tanner's research, shaping their perspectives on early Mormon doctrine and history.
Deep dives
Mary Ann Angel's Resilience
Mary Ann Angel, the wife of Brigham Young and Sandra Tanner's ancestor, faced significant challenges when she married Young shortly after the death of his first wife. Taking on two young stepchildren, she exemplified remarkable fortitude and love as a pioneer, adapting to the pressures of polygamous living. After about ten years together, Young entered into polygamy, which separated Mary Ann from him emotionally and physically as he took on numerous other wives. Ultimately, she ended her years in a house away from the more significant family gatherings, dealing with the loneliness that accompanied such a situation.
Brigham Young Jr.'s Complex Legacy
Sandra Tanner reflected on the life of Brigham Young Jr., her great-grandfather, who became well-known but was often absent due to his extensive travels and church responsibilities. His marriage to Abby Stevens, which took place when she was only 17, reflects the complexities of relationships within early Mormon culture, particularly regarding age differences and societal expectations. Tanner fondly recounted memories of visiting her great-grandmother in her later years, highlighting her grandmother's nurturing nature in creating toys and sharing pioneer stories that shaped her understanding of family history. Furthermore, the narratives surrounding Brigham Young Jr.'s evasions from the law during polygamy contributed to a broader understanding of challenges faced by families during that tumultuous time.
Mountain Meadows Massacre Acknowledgment
The Mountain Meadows Massacre is a crucial aspect of Sandra Tanner's family history, as her ancestors were involved in this tragic event without her prior knowledge. When she discovered the connection during a reprint of John D. Lee's Confessions, it opened discussions within her family about the massacre and its implications for their lineage. Tanner found it shocking to reconcile her family's participation with the straightforward narratives often presented in the church. In subsequent reconciliation efforts, she engaged with descendants of the victims, emphasizing the importance of addressing historical injustices in a meaningful manner.
The Charismatic James Wardle
James Wardle, a barber in Salt Lake City, served as a critical figure within the Mormon community, renowned for his extensive library and eclectic interests. His unique barbershop became an informal hub for discussions on Mormon history, and he supported young researchers in uncovering historical nuances within early Mormonism. Wardle’s mentoring of figures like Gerald Tanner and his willingness to lend out important works established him as a significant resource. This made his shop a crossroads for activism and scholarly pursuits in Mormon studies, leaving a lasting legacy through the people he influenced.
Lamar Peterson's Mentorship
Lamar Peterson, a skilled pianist and former potential church organist, played an essential role in shaping the Tanner's approach to understanding Mormon history. Known for his kindness and respect, he offered guidance and resources to the young couple, sparking their intellectual curiosity about early Mormon doctrine. Peterson's insights into the historical accuracy of the Book of Mormon, paired with his own experiences, challenged their previously held beliefs and refined their understanding of their heritage. This mentorship created a foundation that deepened their research efforts and ultimately shaped their future work in the complex landscape of Mormonism.
Influential Interviews with John Dehlin
Sandra Tanner's journey back into the public consciousness gathered momentum when she participated in an extensive interview with John Dehlin on Mormon Stories. Initially hesitant about the format and its intentions, she ultimately embraced the opportunity, which revitalized her influence in discussions on faith and history. The interview allowed her to articulate her experiences and knowledge, engaging with both supporters and critics alike. Following this exposure, Tanner developed a renewed platform to discuss polygamy, faith transitions, and historical context, significantly increasing her visibility within the ex-Mormon community.
This video features Sandra Tanner, a descendant of Brigham Young, sharing insights into her family history and involvement in Mormon history. From Brigham Young's legal wife, Mary Ann Angell, to descendants of the Mountain Meadows Massacre, Sandra delves into the complexities of her heritage and polygamy's impact on her upbringing.
The discussion explores Sandra's journey into Mormon historical research with her late husband, Jerald, encounters with figures like Ogden Kraut and Ervil LeBaron, and her work with notable journalists and podcasters, including Wallace Turner, Peggy Fletcher Stack, and John Dehlin. This episode offers a fascinating look at the intersections of faith, history, and media.