Legal analyst Elie Mystal of The Nation joins Jason Johnson to discuss recent Supreme Court decisions, including implications on presidential immunity, regulatory power, bribery laws, criminalizing homelessness, and the state of democracy. They emphasize potential consequences for American democracy and the need for citizen activism in shaping political outcomes.
Presidents granted broad immunity for criminal acts while in office, undermining checks and balances.
Supreme Court's control over regulatory matters increased, impacting key areas like environmental protection.
Deep dives
Supreme Court's Decision on Presidential Immunity
The recent Supreme Court session led to a decision granting presidents broad immunity from criminal acts while in office, regardless of whether they are considered official acts or not. This newfound immunity places immense power in the hands of the Court, overshadowing Congress and the President's authority. The ruling creates a loophole where almost any action by the President can be deemed official, leaving ambiguity in distinguishing between official and unofficial acts.
Impact of Overturning Chevron Deference
The Supreme Court's overturning of the Chevron deference doctrine, which allowed agencies to interpret ambiguous laws, marks a significant shift. This decision gives the Court unprecedented control over regulatory matters, affecting critical areas like environmental protection. By usurping legislative and executive powers, the Court's decision alters the fundamental balance of governance.
Controversial Rulings on Bribery and Homelessness
In a concerning ruling on bribery, the Court's definition of 'gratuity' enables public officials to accept post-decision payments without penalty. This decision, coupled with another ruling on criminalizing homelessness, highlights a trend where specific groups are exempted from legal accountability. Such rulings reflect a dangerous consolidation of power within the Court, raising questions about checks and balances in the American democratic system.
This year’s Supreme Court session loosened laws on official bribery, overturned decades of precedent on regulation, and granted immunity to the president for official actions. On today’s episode of A Word, Jason Johnson is joined by legal analyst Elie Mystal of The Nation. They review the Court’s most important decisions, and talk about the political implications and the potential fall out for ordinary Americans.
Guest: Legal analyst Elie Mystal
Podcast production by Kristie Taiwo-Makanjuola
Want more A Word? Subscribe to Slate Plus to immediately access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Or, visit slate.com/awordplus to get access wherever you listen.