Michael Lofton discusses the new schism in Eastern Orthodoxy and the ordination of deaconesses, highlighting debates on ecclesiology, church hierarchies, and the differences in views on women's ordination between the Catholic and Orthodox Churches. The narrative also explores the potential impacts on ecumenical relations, concerns about secularization in the Orthodox Church, and critiques of Pride Month's celebration of sinful acts.
Moscow severed communion with Constantinople over recognition of Ukrainian Orthodox, intensifying schism in Eastern Orthodoxy.
Orthodox unity essential for successful negotiations with Rome, yet internal divisions hinder progress and reconciliation efforts.
The ordination of Deaconess Angelic in Zimbabwe sparks doctrinal debates and potential future conflicts within Orthodoxy.
Deep dives
Internal Schism in Eastern Orthodoxy
The Patriarchate of Moscow has severed communion with Constantinople due to a dispute over recognizing Ukrainian Orthodox groups. Moscow accuses Constantinople of fostering schism by validating Ukrainian Orthodox not recognized by Moscow, leading to increasing schism in Eastern Orthodoxy. Moscow questions Constantinople's authority to determine Church recognition, echoing debates from the first millennium.
Challenges of Dialogue and Reunion
The rift within Eastern Orthodoxy complicates dialogue with Rome for potential reunion. Negotiations require a united Orthodox front; however, with ongoing division, negotiating parties within Orthodoxy are fragmented and lack a unified approach towards reconciliation. Past schisms show that unity is essential for fruitful discussions and agreements.
Controversy Over Female Deacon Ordinations
The Patriarchate of Alexandria recently ordained Deaconess Angelic, sparking ecumenical and doctrinal debates. This move renews the role of deaconesses historically, potentially setting a precedent for sacramental ordinational women in the Orthodox Church. While some embrace this change, others challenge the traditional and doctrinal implications, signaling division and further doctrinal controversies in Orthodoxy.
Impact on Interfaith Relations
The ordination of Deaconess Angelic in Zimbabwe marks a significant shift in Orthodox practices and opens the path for future deaconess ordinations. While some view this as a progressive move honoring female ministry, it also raises doctrinal challenges and hampers chances of unity between the Catholic Church and Orthodox churches. The emergence of female deacons may further complicate ecumenical dialogue and interfaith relations.
Debate over Deaconesses in Orthodoxy
The Orthodox community faces internal debate regarding the ordination of deaconesses. Some rejoice at the news, feeling it brings the community to its senses, while others are surprised and uninformed about this historical tradition. On the opposing side, there are naysayers who vehemently oppose the idea, claiming it goes against tradition, while others respectfully challenge the misinformation spread, clarifying that deaconesses ordained in the ancient world. This debate highlights a divergence within Orthodoxy regarding the role of deaconesses.
Orthodox Resistance to Modern Ideologies
There is a growing concern within Orthodoxy about the influence of modern societal trends on traditional beliefs. The podcast underscores a fear of secularization and compromise with contemporary values, citing examples like the legalization of same-sex marriage in Orthodox countries. Critics within Orthodoxy warn against bending to societal pressures, emphasizing the need to remain steadfast in traditional teachings. The episode raises questions about the potential impact of ongoing internal debates on the Orthodoxy as it navigates through cultural shifts.