In this discussion, John Ibbitson, a regular contributor and bestselling author, dives into the role of the Laurentian elites in Canadian politics. He explores how these elites have historically shaped governance and societal issues, leaving many provinces feeling excluded. The podcast critiques not only the achievements and setbacks of the Trudeau government but also examines the political resurgence of a new coalition within the Conservative Party. Ibbitson provides insights on how demographic changes impact power dynamics, encouraging a deeper understanding of elitism in Canada.
The Laurentian elites have historically shaped Canada's governance through consensus but face growing criticism for exclusionary practices towards Western provinces.
Despite economic challenges and criticism under Justin Trudeau, the recent election reaffirmed the enduring power of the Laurentian elite in Canadian politics.
Deep dives
Defining the Laurentian Elite
The Laurentian elites refer to a group of influential figures in Canadian society, primarily located in Southern Ontario and Quebec, encompassing domains such as politics, business, and media. This elite has played a significant role in shaping Canada's governance through consensus-driven approaches over the past two centuries. However, this historical governance has not been without its challenges, including notable divisions on crucial issues like conscription and Quebec's role in Canada. The elite's impact on the country's status quo raises questions about their inclusivity and how they relate to other regional and class dynamics, particularly as Western provinces like Alberta and Saskatchewan often feel excluded from this central narrative.
The Mixed Legacy of the Trudeau Government
The past decade is characterized by a perceived decline in several key economic metrics, which some attribute to mismanagement by the current Laurentian elite, particularly under Justin Trudeau's leadership. Although Trudeau's government can take credit for successfully renegotiating trade agreements and managing the pandemic effectively, there are notable failures such as flawed industrial policies and an immigration system that has led to societal discontent. Critics argue that the reliance on immigration has caused a backlash that could undermine Canada's multicultural identity, highlighting a troubling legacy of the last decade. The discussion explores how these missteps could signal a broader discontent with the Laurentian elite's influence over governance and cultural narratives.
Election Insights and the Resurgence of Laurentian Elites
The recent election is seen as a critical moment for the Laurentian elite, underscoring their resilience in the political landscape despite challenges from emerging conservative coalitions. These coalitions, which include Western voters and those from Ontario’s 905 region, were expected to pose a formidable threat, particularly given earlier indications of Conservative popularity. However, the election results revealed a reassertion of the Laurentin elite's influence, culminating in a victory for the Liberal Party, despite the Conservatives' strong performance. This outcome suggests that the Laurentian elite, represented by figures like Mark Carney, continue to wield significant power and maintain their relevance in shaping Canada's political and economic future.
