How ‘Vice’ Went from a $6 Billion Media Empire to Bankruptcy
May 30, 2024
58:36
auto_awesome Snipd AI
Explore the rise and fall of media giant Vice, from a $6 billion empire to bankruptcy. Insider insights reveal how identity politics and apologies for gonzo journalism led to its demise. Learn about the challenges of navigating journalism values in a changing media landscape.
Read more
AI Summary
Highlights
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Vice's downfall was accelerated by shifting to a politically charged platform, abandoning its original edgy content.
Internal cultural shifts towards identity politics led to decreased audience engagement and diluted storytelling.
Vice's financial struggles were worsened by prioritizing divisive identity narratives over journalistic integrity, impacting reputation.
Deep dives
Transformation of Vice from Punk Rock to Politicized Platform
Vice, once known for its irreverent, punk rock approach to journalism, started morphing into a heavily politicized platform around 2014. The shift towards a more political and identity-focused agenda slowly replaced the early days of Vice's raw and edgy content. As the company professionalized and hired journalists with specific ideologies, the focus on identity issues and political narratives dominated the content, deviating from the original essence that attracted audiences.
Internal Cultural Shift and Impact on Journalism
Internally, Vice underwent a cultural transformation characterized by an intense focus on race, identity, and political correctness. The company implemented initiatives like anti-racism training and affinity groups, shaping a deeply ideological environment. This shift influenced journalism practices, leading to stories and headlines geared towards specific identity groups, often receiving minimal engagement despite the award recognition Vice garnered.
Erosion of Journalism Standards and Business Decisions
Vice's decline was exacerbated by a series of questionable business decisions and editorial directions. Despite layoffs and financial struggles, Vice pursued projects like 'Black Plus' and exclusive fellowships for non-white journalists, raising concerns about prioritizing identity over journalistic integrity. The focus on divisive identity-driven narratives overshadowed the core purpose of engaging storytelling, contributing to Vice's financial woes and reputation decline.
Challenges Faced in a Changing Workplace Culture
The podcast episode explores the challenges faced by individuals in a changing workplace culture, where outspokenness and diverging opinions may not always be well-received. The speaker shares insights on how some individuals, despite agreeing with certain viewpoints, may choose not to speak up due to personal reasons like family or job security. Specific examples from the podcast highlight the presence of a quiet circle of like-minded individuals who acknowledged similar perspectives, showcasing the complex dynamics within work environments.
Impact of Business Models on Media Outlets
Another key theme discussed in the podcast is the impact of changing business models on media outlets, using Vice as a focal point. The episode delves into the challenges faced by media organizations in monetizing their content effectively amid shifting digital landscapes. Specific examples from Vice's history, including missed opportunities like declining a lucrative acquisition offer, highlight the consequences of lacking a sustainable digital strategy. The conversation emphasizes the need for viable business models in journalism and the repercussions of failing to adapt to evolving industry trends.
Fifteen years ago, Vice was the envy of the media industry. While other outlets were shrinking, the edgy multimedia organization with a knack for virality was growing. At its peak, Vice had a reported value of $6 billion.
At one point, Disney offered to buy the company for $3.4 billion. The CEO said no. Something even bigger was on the horizon.
Except. . . it never came. No one else approached with another offer and the company started to collapse. Last year, Vice filed for bankruptcy.
The media narrative of what happened at Vice was that they simply made a series of business mistakes and the economic model of the business crumbled. But Michael Moynihan says that’s not the whole story.
Michael—who Honestly listeners know as a frequent guest host here—is a longtime journalist who spent a decade at Vice. He was a correspondent for Vice’s flagship series on HBO.
Today, he published a revealing insider story in The Free Press about how Vicereally lost its way. Spoiler: apologizing for the gonzo journalism that fueled the business to begin with, and caving to an identity politics–obsessed staff of twentysomethings, isn’t exactly a recipe for success.
Vice didn’t just bleed cash. It also bled its backbone and its ethos. And the thing that replaced it? Well, no one wanted to consume it.