YCBK 453: How To Know If Your Student Is Competitive At An Honors College
Aug 1, 2024
auto_awesome
Stephen Burd, an expert in enrollment management and editor of a notable book on the topic, shares insightful thoughts on college admissions. He dives into the competitive landscape of honors colleges and discusses the ethical dilemmas surrounding financial aid practices. Burd highlights how some institutions leverage financial aid unethically and critiques firms tracking student web activity for admissions decisions. The conversation also touches on the importance of transparency for families navigating this complex landscape.
Understanding the distinct advantages and offerings of Honors Colleges is essential for evaluating their true value at specific institutions.
Competitiveness for honors programs is determined by analyzing published admissions criteria, academic profiles, and departmental standards at universities.
Demonstrated interest can significantly influence college admissions outcomes, so students should be mindful of how their specific interests are perceived by admissions officers.
Deep dives
The Role of Honors Colleges in Admissions
Honors Colleges offer distinct advantages at various universities, often providing unique resources, scholarships, and specialized classes. However, the structure and benefits associated with these programs can differ significantly between institutions; some offer extensive perks, while others may only provide nominal distinctions. For students primarily interested in an Honors College, understanding the specific offerings and comparison to regular college admissions is crucial. This discrepancy emphasizes the need for prospective students to thoroughly research and evaluate the true value of an Honors College at their institution of interest.
Assessing Competitiveness for Honors Colleges
Determining competitiveness for honors programs typically involves analyzing academic profiles and departmental admission standards. Generally, honors colleges are affiliated with less selective universities, allowing students with higher academic achievements to gain entry. Students are encouraged to review the admissions criteria published on university websites, which often include GPA and standardized test score ranges, to better understand their standing. Overall, proactive research and reliance on available data can illuminate a student's potential for acceptance into these programs.
Demonstrating Interest Applied to Admissions
Demonstrated interest can play a critical role in college admissions, influencing universities' decisions on who receives financial aid and admission offers. Some institutions may overlook prospective students' enthusiasm if it primarily hinges upon their interest in specific programs, like honors colleges, rather than the institution as a whole. While colleges typically signal when they utilize interest in their admissions processes, students often get the impression that demonstrating interest is essential for a positive outcome. Parents should be cautious; revealing that students are only interested in a college for its honors program might be perceived negatively by admissions officers.
Questions Regarding Honors and Awards in College Applications
The inclusion of various honors and awards in college applications can significantly impact a student's perceived qualifications. High school students can list sports awards, arts recognitions, and achievements from extracurricular activities, but they must emphasize the most impactful experiences rather than inundating their resumes with less significant recognitions. National Honor Society memberships, as well as honors received in academic subjects, are valuable to mention, as they demonstrate a well-rounded individual. Ultimately, presenting a concise, prioritized list of accomplishments allows applicants to effectively highlight their strengths.
Navigating College Application Procedures
Each college's application process can vary widely, often involving specific deadlines and criteria for admission into honors colleges and regular programs. Deadlines like early action dates can provide advantages in applying, particularly when it comes to securing housing options. Understanding the entirety of application requirements is essential, as students may face additional essay prompts or questions specifically tailored to the honors college. Likewise, recognizing the importance of maintaining communication with college admissions offices can help students manage their application paths effectively.
Trends in College Enrollment Management
Enrollment management practices and their ethical implications form a crucial conversation surrounding the landscape of college admissions. Often, colleges use comprehensive data mining to assess applicants' demonstrated interest, utilizing this information to influence financial aid decisions and yield rates. The conversation reveals an increasing concern over the transparency of admission practices, with some colleges employing strategies that prioritize institutional needs over student welfare. This intricate dynamic underscores the importance of informed decision-making for students and families navigating the ever-complex world of college admissions.
In this episode you will hear: (02:36) In the News Mark and Julia answer several question from Assaf from Rochester. He has several questions about Honors College’s (23:45) Question from a listener: Our roundtable is back (Hillary, Susan, Julia, Vince and Mark) and we discuss a few questions from an anonymous mom about the Honors section of the Common App. (39:50) Interview Mark interviews Stephen Burd, Editor of the book, Lifting the Veil on Enrollment Management, and Don Hossler, one of the major contributors to the book Preview of Part 3 § Stephan and Don talk about some firms leverage financial aid for every single student and Don uses the word, “repulsive” when referring to this practice § Don tells a story about a dastardly thing he heard one of the bigger firms says at an admissions conference § Mark asks Don another tough question about financial aid leveraging and he lets us know if he finds the practice ethical or unethical § Mark asks Don if he feel colleges tracking your web activity and factoring that into decisions, does he see this as ethical or unethical? § Don tells us whether more public universities are using demonstrated interest than they often let families know § Stephen talks about another practice he finds to be unethical in recruitment § Don talks about a director of admission that got fired because the President intentionally wanted him to recruit to reject and he refused to recruit with the purpose of rejecting more students, so he got fired § Stephen talks about how all of this financial leveraging is hurting colleges financially § Stephen tells us who he feels is really being hurt by all of this financial aid leveraging § Stephen and Don go on the hotseat (57:43) Recommended Resource: How to Raise Successful Kids -- Without Over-Parenting | Julie Lythcott-Haims | TED (01:13:32) College Spotlight-University of South Carolina Part 2 of 3 with Mark and Lisa Speakpipe.com/YCBK is our method if you want to ask a question and we will be prioritizing all questions sent in via Speakpipe. Unfortunately, we will NOT answer questions on the podcast anymore that are emailed in. If you want us to answer a question on the podcast, please use speakpipe.com/YCBK. We feel hearing from our listeners in their own voices adds to the community feel of our podcast. You can also use this for many other purposes: 1) Send us constructive criticism about how we can improve our podcast 2) Share an encouraging word about something you like about an episode or the podcast in general 3) Share a topic or an article you would like us to address 4) Share a speaker you want us to interview 5) Leave positive feedback for one of our interviewees. We will send your verbal feedback directly to them and I can almost assure you, your positive feedback will make their day. To sign up to receive Your College-Bound Kid PLUS, our new monthly admissions newsletter, delivered directly to your email once a month, just go to yourcollegeboundkid.com, and you will see the sign-up popup. We will include many of the hot topics being discussed on college campuses. Check out our new blog. We write timely and insightful articles on college admissions: Follow Mark Stucker on Twitter to get breaking college admission news, and updates about the podcast before they go live. You can ask questions on Twitter that he will answer on the podcast. Mark will also share additional hot topics in the news and breaking news on this Twitter feed. Twitter message is also the preferred way to ask questions for our podcast: https://twitter.com/YCBKpodcast 1. To access our transcripts, click: https://yourcollegeboundkid.com/category/transcripts/ 2. Find the specific episode transcripts for the one you want to search and click the link 3. Find the magnifying glass icon in blue (search feature) and click it 4. Enter whatever word you want to search. I.e. Loans 5. Every word in that episode when the words loans are used, will be highlighted in yellow with a timestamps 6. Click the word highlighted in yellow and the player will play the episode from that starting point 7. You can also download the entire podcast as a transcript We would be honored if you will pass this podcast episode on to others who you feel will benefit from the content in YCBK. Please subscribe to our podcast. It really helps us move up in Apple’s search feature so others can find our podcast. If you enjoy our podcast, would you please do us a favor and share our podcast both verbally and on social media? We would be most grateful! If you want to help more people find Your College-Bound Kid, please make sure you follow our podcast. You will also get instant notifications as soon as each episode goes live. Check out the college admissions books Mark recommends: Check out the college websites Mark recommends: If you want to have some input about what you like and what you recommend, we change about our podcast, please complete our Podcast survey; here is the link: If you want a college consultation with Mark or Lisa or Lynda, just text Mark at 404-664-4340 or email Lisa at or Lynda at Lynda@schoolmatch4u.com. All we ask is that you review their services and pricing on their website before the complimentary session; here is link to their services with transparent pricing: https://schoolmatch4u.com/services/compare-packages/
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode