Matt Taibbi, an independent journalist known for his insights on media bias, discusses Wikipedia's treatment of RCP's polling average and the media's influence in the election. Tim Shriver, CEO of UNITE, emphasizes the need for civil political dialogue in today's divisive climate, urging citizens to engage respectfully. Nellie Bowles, columnist and author, reflects on the evolving landscape of activism and journalism, delving into themes of cancel culture and societal change. Each guest brings a unique perspective on improving public discourse and understanding in a polarized world.
The podcast discusses the impact of media biases on public perceptions of polling data, particularly concerning Real Clear Politics' polling average amidst criticism from major outlets.
Emphasizing the need for respectful political dialogue, Tim Shriver advocates for fostering dignity and common humanity in national discussions to combat divisive rhetoric.
Deep dives
The Challenge of Polling Integrity
The conversation emphasizes concerns regarding the integrity of polling data, particularly in the context of Real Clear Politics (RCP) and its treatment in mainstream media. Critics argue that coverage from outlets like The New York Times has misrepresented Republican polling averages, attributing skewed perceptions to an alleged bias that favors Donald Trump. This scrutiny extends to platforms like Wikipedia, which have removed RCP from national polling pages, impacting its reliability as a sourcing entity. The notion that official endorsement and editor biases could affect public perceptions underlines the contentious dynamics in political reporting and information sharing.
Censorship and Big Tech's Role
Matt Taibbi discusses the evolving landscape of online information, where big tech companies, such as Facebook and Google, are perceived as complicit in a 'censorship cartel.' He highlights the increasing reliance on rating systems and fact-checking organizations, which often reflect a bias against conservative viewpoints. This results in a significant impact on the visibility of certain reporting, as evidenced by how opinions critical of the government may be downgraded by entities like NewsGuard. The conversation underscores the challenges journalists face in disseminating diverse views amid growing censorship pressures.
The Need for Dignity in Discourse
Tim Shriver discusses the importance of fostering dignity in political dialogue, noting the growing contempt in national discussions that often dismiss common humanity. The idea is that many citizens, regardless of party affiliation, share a desire for a better America, yet the discourse is plagued by dehumanizing language. Shriver calls for creating environments where political disagreements can be expressed without animosity and asserts that individuals can still respectfully engage without compromising their values or opinions. The focus on positive engagement highlights a potential path toward healing and unity in divided politics.
Complexity of Modern Anti-Racism
Nellie Bowles explores the transition of anti-racism discourse from traditional activism that sought legislative change to a more introspective approach that emphasizes 'excavating one's whiteness.' This shift is characterized by a therapeutic model where self-examination supplants actionable efforts, with individuals encouraged to identify and confront their implicit biases. Bowles critiques the inherent contradictions in this movement, revealing how such beliefs can create a false dichotomy that alienates those who seek to engage with nuance. The chapter exposes the broader implications of these discussions on national dialogue and individual identity.
Today's podcast is a flashback episode. First, Tom Bevan talks to Twitter Files author Matt Taibbi about Wikipedia’s removal of the RCP Polling Average before the election and the New York Times criticism of RCP for not weighing its averages. Next, Carl Cannon interviews Tim Shriver, CEO and founder of UNITE, about what Americans can do to improve our public dialogue in the impending second Trump era. And finally, Andrew Walworth talks to author Nellie Bowles, columnist for the Free Press and author of the new book "Morning After the Revolution: Dispatches from the Wrong Side of History".
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode