The Enlightenment Was a Disaster - Johann Kurtz | Maiden Mother Matriarch Episode 112
Jan 22, 2025
auto_awesome
In this episode, Johann Kurtz, a pseudonymous author known for his insights on historical fertility and social status, delves into intriguing dynamics between status and reproduction. He discusses how social hierarchies influence fertility trends, challenging traditional views of wealth and religion's roles. Kurtz also explores the Enlightenment's paradox, revealing its unexpected impact on birth rates. With compelling case studies from Georgia and South Korea, he examines how status shapes parenthood choices and critiques contemporary narratives around women's roles in family planning.
The decline in fertility rates is significantly linked to diminishing social prestige associated with motherhood rather than solely economic factors.
Kurtz highlights that high-fertility countries often remain impoverished, challenging the assumption that wealth directly influences reproductive decisions.
Cultural shifts toward individual meritocracy have altered societal expectations, making child-rearing appear as a barrier to achieving higher social status.
Deep dives
The Decline of Fertility and Social Status
The discussion highlights the long-term decline in fertility rates across various countries, notably Britain. Johan Kurtz argues that traditional explanations, such as increased wealth and religiosity, overlook a crucial factor: social status. His thesis suggests that the decreased social prestige associated with motherhood plays a significant role in reproductive choices. As social dynamics evolve, the societal valuation of motherhood diminishes, leading to lower fertility rates.
Economic Factors vs. Socio-Cultural Influences
The podcast confronts the common narrative that economic constraints are the primary deterrent to having children. While affordability is often cited by young people as a concern, data reveals a more complex interplay between fertility rates and economic conditions. Notably, many high-fertility countries remain impoverished, challenging the idea that affluence directly influences reproductive choices. Similarly, extensive state investment in fertility incentives, as seen in Hungary and South Korea, has failed to yield meaningful increases in birth rates.
The Role of Religion in Fertility Trends
Kurtz discusses the correlation between religious observance and fertility but points out that historical fertility declines predate substantial changes in religiosity. By analyzing U.S. fertility data over centuries, he notes that despite the apparent consistent decline in birth rates, religious attendance had not experienced a similar decline. This raises questions about the effectiveness of religion in addressing modern fertility issues, especially as the fertility rates among religious individuals in today’s society remain below replacement level.
Status Dynamics and Individual Choices
The conversation delves into how societal expectations around status influence individual decisions concerning parenthood. In contemporary society, the pursuit of higher social status often drives people to prioritize careers and other pursuits over raising children. Changes stemming from the Enlightenment shifted status assignment from communal and familial ties to individual meritocracy, complicating family dynamics. This cultural transformation creates a landscape where having children can be seen as a hindrance to achieving higher social standing.
Comparative Case Studies: Georgia and South Korea
Two contrasting case studies are presented to illustrate how shifts in societal perception of status can dramatically affect fertility rates. In Georgia, a surprising 28% increase in birth rates was linked to a religious leader's announcement to personally bless third children, suggesting that elevated status within the community can spur higher fertility. Conversely, South Korea's low birth rates are attributed to intense social pressures and a status-driven economy, discouraging many from having children due to fear of falling behind socially. These examples underscore the intricate relationship between status perceptions and reproductive choices in different cultural contexts.
My guest today is Johann Kurtz, pseudonymous author of the 'Becoming Noble' Substack. We spoke about the long history of falling fertility rates, and particularly about the role of status in explaining the phenomenon.
MMM is sponsored by 321 - a new online introduction to Christianity, presented by former MMM guest Glen Scrivener. Check it out for free a…
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode