Explore the complex life of James VI and I in this court psychodrama. Topics include witch hunts, male favorites, primitive accumulation, and the question of defining 'gay' in the 16th century.
James I faced challenges from the emerging bourgeoisie and Parliament, intensifying clashes between an absolutist monarchy and a developing capitalist society.
The nature of James I's relationships with his favorites remains debated, with interpretations varying based on historical context and understanding of sexuality.
Deep dives
James I and his Turbulent Beginnings
James Charles Stewart, also known as James VI and I, was born in 1566 during a period of intense turmoil in British and European history. His father was murdered when he was only a year old, and he was raised as a Scottish Protestant under the guidance of George Buchanan. James faced battles between Catholic and Protestant supporters, and his mother, Mary Queen of Scots, was imprisoned by Elizabeth I. James eventually became the king of England and Scotland, but his reign was marked by conflicts with Parliament and his attempts to assert absolute power. He also developed a fascination with witchcraft and attended many trials, even writing a book on the subject. Despite his political struggles and personal relationships, such as his marriages and close bonds with favorites like Robert Carr and George Villiers, the nature of these relationships remains debated.
Conflicts with Parliament and the Rise of Capitalism
James I faced challenges from the emerging bourgeoisie and Parliament, who resisted his attempts to exert absolute power. England's economic and social changes, including the dissolution of the monasteries and the enclosures, created a growing capitalist class with political influence. James relied on selling privileges and positions, leading to corruption and resentment. His military involvement in European conflicts, such as supporting French Catholics against Huguenots, stirred opposition among English Protestants. These tensions, along with his patronage system and favoritism, intensified clashes with Parliament and the bourgeoisie, setting the stage for future conflicts between an absolutist monarchy and a developing capitalist society.
The Debate on James' Sexual Relationships
James I's relationships with his favorites, like Robert Carr and George Villiers, have sparked discussions about his sexuality. Letters and quotes suggest a deep emotional and intimate connection between James and these men, but labeling these relationships as gay is complicated. James also had a marriage and children, and his relationships can be seen as political, involving trust, power dynamics, and the dynamics of court life. The nature of these relationships, whether romantic, sexual, or primarily political, continues to be debated, and different interpretations exist based on different understandings of historical context and the nuances of sexuality.
Legacy and Historical Significance
James I's reign laid the groundwork for future political conflicts, such as the English Civil War and the Glorious Revolution. His attempts to assert absolute power, conflicts with Parliament, and favoritism created resentment and opposition from the bourgeoisie and emerging bourgeois landowners. James' fascination with witchcraft and his policies on monopolies also contributed to his legacy. Despite the complexities of his rule and personal relationships, James I remains a significant figure in history, illustrating the challenges of navigating power dynamics, social changes, and the struggle between traditional and emerging systems of governance.
If you liked Yiorgos Lanthinos' court psychodrama The Favourite, you'll love this exploration of the complicated life of James VI and I – a king who united Scotland and England, persecuted witches, and granted his male favorites extraordinary power and privilege. Come for the court drama and stay for in-depth discussions of primitive accumulation and the question of whether using the word 'gay' to describe a 16th-century monarch makes any sense at all.
----more----
Sources:
Anderson, Perry. Lineages of the Absolutist State. London: Verso Books, 1979.
Ackroyd, Peter. Queer City: Gay London from the Romans to the Present Day. London: Chatto and Windniss, 2017.
Bergeron, David. King James and Letters of Homoerotic Desire. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 1999.
Federici, Silvia. Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body, and Primitive Accumulation. New York: Autonomedia, 2002.
Holstun, James. Ehud’s Dagger: Class Struggle in the English Revolution. London: Verso Books, 2002.