From Hamas captivity to recovery: the long road ahead for Israel's freed hostages
Jan 31, 2025
auto_awesome
In this insightful discussion, Professor Hagai Levine, a public health expert and head of the health team for the Hostages Family Forum, dives into the intricacies faced by hostages freed from Hamas. He explores the psychological and physical challenges that arise post-captivity, stressing the urgent need for comprehensive long-term care. Levine addresses the troubling gaps in government support for these individuals and families, and highlights the importance of advocacy from humanitarian organizations to ensure adequate recovery resources.
Freed hostages from Hamas captivity face complex, long-term health and emotional challenges due to inadequate government support and rehabilitation plans.
There is a pressing need for global humanitarian organizations to advocate more effectively for hostages' rights, emphasizing equitable treatment amidst political biases.
Deep dives
The Condition of Freed Hostages
The recent releases of hostages from Hamas captivity after extensive periods have raised concerns about their physical and mental well-being. While the initial return appearances have shown some hostages seemingly in good health, deeper issues may still exist beneath the surface. Medical professionals emphasize that without proper treatment during captivity, long-term health implications could arise, especially since many hostages may have underlying medical conditions. The emotional state of the hostages is also a critical aspect to consider, as they struggle with guilt and the burden of their friends and loved ones who remain in captivity.
Urgency for Comprehensive Rehabilitation Plans
There is an urgent need for established rehabilitation plans for freed hostages, particularly as the government has been slow to respond to their unique needs. Although there have been some improvements, such as the establishment of specialized clinics and multidisciplinary teams for care, challenges persist as long as hostages are still being held. Many families of the hostages continue to feel overlooked, lacking adequate support from the government to address their trauma. A holistic national program is necessary to promote recovery for all affected individuals and communities and address their distinct experiences.
Global Humanitarian Response and Responsibilities
The response of global humanitarian organizations to the plight of hostages has been viewed as lacking, with a call for these entities to acknowledge the rights of the hostages equitably. Although efforts have been made to communicate the medical conditions faced by hostages, there is disappointment that organizations like the Red Cross and the World Health Organization have not done enough to advocate for the hostages due to political biases. The limitations of these organizations in impacting the situation highlight a need for a more robust system that prioritizes human lives and rights across the board. This ongoing humanitarian crisis underscores the importance of a consistent and fair approach by global bodies towards victims of conflict.
After months in Hamas captivity, the release of some Israeli hostages has brought moments of relief - but also difficult questions. While the public sees smiling faces and embraces, the reality behind the scenes is far more complex.
In this episode, Haaretz Podcast host Allison Kaplan Sommer speaks with Professor Hagai Levine, head of the health team for the Hostages Family Forum and chairman of the Israeli Association of Public Health Physician.
What happens to a person’s body and mind after being held hostage for over a year? Why is the Israeli government failing to provide proper long-term care for the freed hostages? And what needs to be done - urgently - to rescue those who are still trapped in Gaza?