WOF 480: Are We Required to Love Everyone Equally?
Mar 10, 2025
auto_awesome
Is love in Christianity truly equal for everyone? The podcast explores diverse types of love, from familial bonds to loving one's enemies. It questions the moral obligations we hold towards different relationships. The concept of 'neighbor' is dissected, revealing how obligations shift depending on circumstances. Insights on self-love and forgiveness are discussed, along with the influence of love in evangelization. The balance between personal responsibilities and caring for others in need adds depth to the conversation.
Christian love involves willing the good of the other, recognizing that different relationships entail varying levels of moral obligation.
The Order of Love highlights the need for prioritizing certain relationships, as love may require responding to immediate needs distinctively.
Deep dives
Understanding the Nature of Christian Love
Christian love is fundamentally defined as willing the good of the other, a perspective rooted in the teachings of Thomas Aquinas. This love extends not only to God but also connects to the love of neighbor, highlighting that if one loves God genuinely, they are inclined to love what God loves. This definition raises complex questions surrounding the differentiation in types of love, such as love for friends, family, and even enemies, necessitating a deeper inquiry into the intensity and obligation associated with each type of love. By recognizing that all forms of love involve a different measure of moral responsibility, Christians can navigate the challenge of loving equally while acknowledging the varied degrees of obligation in relationships, as illustrated by Cardinal George's interpretation of God's love for creation as uneven, depending on the good willed for each being.
The Order of Love and Moral Obligations
The concept of the Order of Love emphasizes that not all individuals should be loved equally to the same degree, pointing to moral obligations arising from proximity and relational context. Aquinas and Augustine highlight that individuals, especially within a family unit, have prioritization in their duties of love, as seen in scenarios where a person must first protect their family before assisting external needs. When immediate needs arise, such as someone in crisis presenting themselves, the Order of Love can be temporarily suspended, allowing for a response to urgent circumstances. This nuanced approach acknowledges that while every human holds immeasurable dignity, the moral responsibility to prioritize certain relationships exists, which is crucial for effective love and care.
Distinguishing Christian Love from Secular Understanding
Christian love can often clash with contemporary secular interpretations, which equate love with uncritical affirmation of personal choices. This distinction is essential as authentic love sometimes requires challenging others' decisions for their own good, akin to a parent guiding a child away from harmful choices. Understanding love in this context includes recognizing that acts of true love can include critique and intervention when necessary, rather than mere validation. By affirming that love is not merely about doing what others want, but about striving for their genuine good, Christians can effectively engage with cultural conversations on love, demonstrating that this love operates from a position of deep care and moral responsibility.
Are Christians required to love everyone equally? This question has recently become a matter of public and even political debate. So how should we answer? It seems necessary to ask what “loving thy neighbor” means in practice; for example is the love between friends, the love between spouses, the love within a family, the love among compatriots, and even the love of an enemy all the same kind of love? Do these relationships all entail the same kinds of moral responsibilities? Might it be reasonable to say, for example, that we have a greater obligation to care for our own children over others’ children, our own friends over strangers, and our own country over other countries? If so, however, how can Christians coherently claim that we love all people equally?
A listener asks how to forgive and let go of bitterness. I help my kids return to church?
00:00 | Introduction 01:43 | Bishop Barron’s recent trip to London 02:08 | Understanding love in the great commandments 03:50 | Love for specific relationships 06:13 | Properly framing love of self 06:58 | Love your enemies 08:03 | Critiquing love as granting another’s desires 09:07 | The distinct love for God 11:17 | Who is my neighbor? 12:55 | Ordo amoris: the order of love 17:52 | Equal regard vs. equal treatment 20:36 | Is it ever okay to circumvent ordo amoris? 22:20 | Does the Good Samaritan counter ordo amoris? 23:40 | Does Luke 9:60 counter ordo amoris? 26:52 | The evangelical impact of understanding love 27:43 | Listener question 29:54 | Join the Word on Fire Institute
NOTE: Do you like this podcast? Become a Word on Fire IGNITE member! Word on Fire is a non-profit ministry that depends on the support of our listeners . . . like you! So become a part of this mission and join IGNITE today to become a Word on Fire insider and receive some special donor gifts for your generosity.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode