This podcast delves into Hegel's examination of culture, religion, and art in his Phenomenology of Spirit. It explores the role of religion in modern life and its relationship to other forms of life. It also discusses Hegel's critique of utilitarianism and Kant's deontology, highlighting the relativistic nature of Kant's ethics. Additionally, it delves into Hegel's concept of sittlicite, emphasizing the importance of shared commitments for a flourishing ethical culture. The podcast also explores the rationality of political structures and the fragility of reconciliation.
Hegel emphasizes the connection between art and the absolute, where true art addresses the dissolution of the self and provides a reflection of our place in the infinite.
Hegel argues that individual freedom is only meaningful within a network of social goods and institutions that enable collaboration and mutual recognition.
Deep dives
Understanding Spirit and its Manifestations
Hegel examines the concepts of Spirit, reason, and understanding in the latter part of 'Phenomenology of Spirit.' He discusses how human spirit is divided into drives towards unity and fragmentation and explores how spirit resolves these conflicts through practical dispositions and competencies. Hegel expands on the idea of spirit by delving into topics like culture, religion, law, and art. He highlights the importance of understanding what it means to exist in a concrete moral life and how competing discourses shape our common life as free individuals.
The Regenerative Power of Art
Hegel defends the regenerative capacities of art, claiming that it was once a universal phenomenon embedded in the ethical substance of culture. However, he argues that early 19th-century German art had become an object of philosophical speculation, leading to its fragmentation and detachment from broader cultural processes. Hegel suggests that art retains value when it reflects philosophical forms of recognition. He emphasizes the connection between art and the absolute, where true art addresses the dissolution of the self and provides a reflection of our place in the infinite.
Religion and its Place in Modernity
Hegel explores religion as a form of consciousness, discussing its role in uniting fragmented thought and apprehending the infinite. He acknowledges that religion is a more sophisticated form of unity compared to other forms of thinking, such as atheism. However, he also notes that religion became contested and fragmented after modernity, coexisting alongside other forms of life like technology and culture. Hegel highlights the tension between religion's emphasis on the all-encompassing divine and the particular expressions found in different religions. Ultimately, he argues that religion holds a contested status in the modern world.
Ethical Life and the Importance of Community
Hegel presents the concept of 'Sittlichkeit' or ethical life as a contrast to individualism in the Enlightenment. He asserts that ethical life encompasses communal practices, including norms, ideals, rituals, and shared commitments that bind individuals in a society. Unlike abstract moral principles, ethical life is concrete and continuously evolving. Hegel argues that individual freedom is only meaningful within a network of social goods and institutions that enable collaboration and mutual recognition. Ethical life fosters a sense of belonging, where individuals disidentify with their own self-interests and engage in the well-being of the community.
This week I am going to look at some key moments in the latter part of the PoS. Primarily, I am going to look at what Hegel has to say about culture and religion, moral theories, and ethical life (sittlichkeit).The latter part of the PoS is concerned with clarifying sets of social practices which count as spirit.
These lectures are brought to you by Staffordshire University's Philosophy team. Come study on our MA in Continental Philosophy via this link. Or, join our MA in Philosophy of Nature, Information and Technology via this link. Find out more about me here.