Legal AF by MeidasTouch Trump Smacked Down by Judge Who Haunted Him in the Past
Apr 22, 2025
A federal judge delivers a scathing critique of the Trump administration's handling of deportations, likening their approach to historical injustices. The discussion dives into the implications of the Alien Enemies Act and the importance of due process for detainees, particularly from crisis-stricken countries. Trump’s ongoing legal battles are spotlighted, especially in relation to the E. Jean Carroll case, underscoring the necessity for fair legal standards and public awareness regarding these pressing issues.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Judge Hellerstein Compares DOJ to Inquisition
- Judge Alvin Hellerstein equated the DOJ's treatment of detainees under the Alien Enemies Act to a medieval Inquisition.
- He insists due process is non-negotiable, rejecting the DOJ's view of "flexible" standards.
Due Process Notice Requirements
- The Supreme Court ruled detainees under the Alien Enemies Act are entitled to notice and a hearing.
- Judge Hellerstein mandated notice must be in English and Spanish with interpreters provided.
Supreme Court Fuels Legal Challenges
- The Supreme Court's ruling forces hundreds of individual habeas corpus petitions challenging removal.
- This disrupts Trump's strategy and allows judges to question the legitimacy of the Alien Enemies Act invocation.