Swethaa S. Ballakrishnen, "Accidental Feminism: Gender Parity and Selective Mobility Among India’s Professional Elite" (Princeton UP, 2021)
Jan 3, 2025
auto_awesome
Swethaa Ballakrishnen, a sociolegal scholar and assistant professor at UC Irvine, discusses her book on gender dynamics in India’s elite law firms. She reveals how structural factors create unexpected gender parity in a male-dominated industry. The conversation explores the complex interplay of socio-economic backgrounds, family dynamics, and changing perceptions of work. Ballakrishnen challenges notions of intentionality in feminism, questioning whether unintentional progress can still be deemed feminist. Intriguing insights abound on navigating gender in India’s professional landscapes.
The concept of 'Accidental Feminism' reveals that gender parity in India's elite law firms results from unique socio-economic conditions rather than intentional feminist policies.
Global economic liberalization post-1991 reshaped the Indian legal profession, creating an environment that allowed women to thrive without the stigma of traditional gender biases.
Women in elite law firms often succeed due to robust familial and social support systems that counterbalance the challenges of their male-dominated profession.
Deep dives
Professor Swetha Balakrishnan's Academic Journey
Professor Swetha Balakrishnan's academic journey began with her undergraduate education at the National Academy of Legal Studies and Research in India, where she graduated in 2004. Following a brief career as a corporate lawyer and teaching, she pursued an LLM at Harvard in 2007, laying the groundwork for her subsequent academic endeavors. Her focus shifted to socio-legal scholarship, particularly the intersection of law, globalization, and social stratification, furthered by a PhD in sociology from Stanford. Through her diverse academic experiences, including a postdoc at NYU Abu Dhabi, she developed a critical feminist perspective that informs her research and publications, including her first book, 'Accidental Feminism.'
The Accidental Feminism Concept
The concept of 'Accidental Feminism' arises from the unexpected gender parity observed in elite corporate law firms in India, where women were advancing at rates comparable to their male counterparts. Balkrishnan's research indicates that this phenomenon is not the result of deliberate feminist reforms but rather the outcome of unique socio-economic conditions that emerged during the globalization of the Indian legal profession post-1991. The discussion challenges traditional narratives that link gender equity directly with intentional policies, suggesting that sometimes progress can happen incidentally without formal feminist agendas. This raises important questions about the nature of feminism and whether unintentional benefits can still contribute to gender equality.
Impact of Globalization on Law Firms
Professor Balakrishnan explores how the 1991 economic liberalization in India transformed the legal profession by introducing global firm structures and practices. This globalization provided an environment conducive to women entering the legal profession, as there were fewer established norms regarding gender roles compared to traditional settings. The significant capital influx and the demand for high-status legal services necessitated a re-evaluation of firm cultures, allowing women to flourish in roles previously dominated by men without the stigma of gender biases evident in other sectors. This transformation not only facilitated women's progress within the firms but also redefined the expectations of professionalism and success in the legal landscape.
Social Support Systems Among Women Lawyers
The success of women in elite corporate law firms is significantly supported by their familial and social networks, which help to navigate the challenges of balancing work and life. Many of these women benefit from a form of collaborative kinship where family members—particularly mothers and in-laws—can provide essential childcare and household support. This support system not only allows them to pursue demanding careers but also shifts traditional gender roles within their households, as perceived by society. Therefore, while they may be entering a male-dominated profession, their success is often contingent upon a network of social support that must be acknowledged and explored further.
The Intersection of Gender and Meritocracy
The book delves into the complexities of meritocracy in the context of Indian corporate law, where gender and merit often intertwine in unexpected ways. Women lawyers find themselves in firms that outwardly claim meritocratic principles, yet their success is tied less to intentional feminist policies and more to structural advantages that emerged organically. This raises critical questions about whether success can genuinely be attributed to merit when prevailing conditions favor certain demographics. Balakrishnan argues that while women navigate these elite spaces, the definitions of merit are shaped by broader societal contexts, effectively blurring the lines of traditional meritocratic frameworks.
In India, elite law firms offer a surprising oasis for women within a hostile, predominantly male industry. Less than 10 percent of the country's lawyers are female, but women in the most prestigious firms are significantly represented both at entry and partnership. Elite workspaces are notorious for being unfriendly to new actors, so what allows for aberration in certain workspaces?
Drawing from observations and interviews with more than 130 elite professionals, Accidental Feminism: Gender Parity and Selective Mobility Among India’s Professional Elite(Princeton UP, 2021) examines how a range of underlying mechanisms-gendered socialization and essentialism, family structures and dynamics, and firm and regulatory histories-afford certain professionals egalitarian outcomes that are not available to their local and global peers. Juxtaposing findings on the legal profession with those on elite consulting firms, Swethaa Ballakrishnen reveals that parity arises not from a commitment to create feminist organizations, but from structural factors that incidentally come together to do gender differently. Simultaneously, their research offers notes of caution: while conditional convergence may create equality in ways that more targeted endeavors fail to achieve, "accidental" developments are hard to replicate, and are, in this case, buttressed by embedded inequalities. Ballakrishnen examines whether gender parity produced without institutional sanction should still be considered feminist.
In offering new ways to think about equality movements and outcomes, Accidental Feminism forces readers to critically consider the work of intention in progress narratives.
Noopur Raval is a postdoctoral researcher working at the intersection of Information Studies, STS, Media Studies and Anthropology.