This podcast explores the history of Britain's relationship with the Israel-Palestine question, including the Balfour Declaration, Britain's withdrawal from Israel-Palestine, the government's changing stance on the conflict, and their role in the aftermath of Israel's creation. It also discusses the shift in the British government's relationship with Israel during the Yom Kippur War and the geopolitical dilemmas faced by Britain in aligning with America.
The historical relationship between Britain and the Israel-Palestine question has been influenced by geopolitical considerations and the changing dynamics of the region.
The 1967 Arab-Israeli war and the rise of the Likud Party have shaped the political perception of Israel and Palestine.
The Israel-Palestine issue within British politics has been intensified by debates around anti-Semitism, making it challenging for leaders like Keir Starmer to navigate the issue.
Deep dives
British policy towards Israel and Palestine has zigzagged since the First World War
Since the endorsement of a Jewish homeland by the British government in 1917, British policy towards Israel and Palestine has undergone numerous shifts. The Balfour Declaration marked a crucial moment in this history, with Labour and the left generally supporting the idea of a Jewish state. However, geopolitical considerations, particularly concerning the Suez Canal, influenced British policy. The closure of the canal by Egypt in 1967 and the subsequent oil crisis further reshaped British interests in the region. This changing dynamic has impacted the British perception of Israel and Palestine, with the left becoming more critical of Israel over time.
The impact of the 1967 Arab-Israeli war
The 1967 Arab-Israeli war brought significant changes to the region. Israel gained control of the West Bank, Gaza, and the Golan Heights, while British interests shifted toward the supply of oil. The war also led to a change in Israeli domestic policy, with the rise of the Likud Party and a move toward the idea of Greater Israel. These developments, alongside geopolitical complexities and the emergence of the new left, have shaped the way Israel and Palestine are viewed politically.
Jeremy Corbyn and the anti-Semitism crisis
Jeremy Corbyn's leadership of the Labour Party reignited debates around the Israel-Palestine issue within British politics. Corby's staunch support for the Palestinian cause, driven by his anti-colonial perspective, encountered criticisms of anti-Semitism within the party. The controversy over Labour's failures in addressing anti-Semitism culminated in the party being investigated by the Equality and Human Rights Commission. The issue of anti-Semitism continues to be a significant challenge for the Labour Party and its leaders, including Keir Starmer.
Shifting perspectives and challenges for Keir Starmer
The view of Israel as a settler colonial country has gained significant traction on the left, making it harder for leaders like Keir Starmer to navigate the Israel-Palestine issue. A divergence of opinion exists within the party, ranging from instinctive support for Israel's right to defend itself to criticism of its policies. Moreover, the wider geopolitical landscape, including the shifting focus to great power competition and other global challenges, adds complexity to the issue. The relationship between British and American politics also influences the domestic debate on Israel and Palestine.
The future of British politics and the Israel-Palestine issue
As geopolitical realities evolve and public sentiment surrounding Israel and Palestine continues to shift, the future of British politics in relation to the issue remains uncertain. The rise of right-wing policies in Israel, the ongoing struggle between different ideological perspectives, and the balance between domestic political pressures and international relations create challenges for leaders like Keir Starmer. Additionally, the changing nature of the geopolitical landscape and potential shifts in US policies may further complicate the decision-making process.
In this episode, Tom and Helen discuss the history of Britain's relationship with the Israel-Palestine question; from Lloyd George and Winston Churchill, to Starmer's recent opposition to calls for ceasefire.