Noam Dworman: Free Speech for All, From Finkelstein to Chapelle
May 8, 2024
auto_awesome
Nick Gillespie interviews Noam Dworman, owner of New York's Comedy Cellar, discussing free speech, comedy culture, anti-Semitism, political correctness, and the history of comedy in Greenwich Village. Dworman shares insights on censorship, the importance of diverse viewpoints, and the evolution of free speech in society, while reflecting on his podcast 'Live From the Table' and personal experiences navigating controversy in comedy clubs.
Comedy Cellar fosters a free speech culture, allowing comedians to push boundaries without fear of repercussions.
Wokeness does not stifle comedy, as proven by the success of comedians like Dave Chappelle and Shane Gillis.
Comedy community reflects diversity with increased representation of women, different ethnicities, LGBTQ+ individuals, and diverse comedic styles.
Deep dives
Evolution of Stand-Up Comedy
Stand-up comedy has seen significant evolution over time, with the current era considered the greatest due to the high level of acts. In the past, acts were touch and go, with only a few standout performances, but now, the majority of acts excel. Established comedians like Chris Rock and John Stewart remain prominent, indicating a lack of turnover at the top levels. Younger comedians have ample opportunities to rise, facilitated by platforms like YouTube.
Impact of Wokeness on Comedy
The narrative that wokeness has negatively impacted comedy is disputed by the owner of Comedy Cellar. While some woke individuals have objected to comedy acts and even caused disruptions, comedians like Dave Chappelle and Shane Gillis continue to flourish. The belief that wokeness has stifled comedy is challenged by the success of comedians who defy these supposed limitations, such as Shane Gillis, Andrew Scholz, and Tim Dillon.
Diversity in Comedy Communities
In the comedy community, a significant shift has occurred in terms of diversity, especially at lower levels. While women's participation has increased, the ethnic composition has seen a more profound change. Various ethnicities, LGBTQ+, and different genders are represented in the comedy scene. The emphasis on diversity and the acceptance of different comedic styles, including those of funny women like Amy Schumer and Ali Wong, reflect a more inclusive environment in comedy clubs.
The Power of Free Speech in Comedy
Free speech is deemed fundamental in comedy clubs like Comedy Cellar, fostering an environment where comedians can push boundaries without fear of repercussions. The open debate, humor, and exchange of ideas in a small, intimate setting like the Comedy Cellar create a vibrant and engaging space for both comedians and audiences. The culture of free speech and expression, along with the ability to engage in heated discussions then reconcile, fosters a robust and dynamic comedy community.
Concerns about COVID-19 Lockdowns and Libertarian Views on Economic Freedom
The podcast episode delves into the host's experience with COVID-19 lockdowns as a small business owner, highlighting his libertarian perspectives on economic freedom and individual rights. He reflects on the challenges faced in decision-making during the pandemic, discussing the balance between following legal obligations and prioritizing the safety of employees. The host emphasizes the importance of trial and error in finding solutions, suggesting the implementation of uniform safety standards like wearing N95 masks for businesses to operate.
Rising Concerns on Anti-Semitism and Critical Analysis of Israel Discourse
The podcast episode shifts to a discussion on rising antisemitism and the complexities of the Israel-Palestine conflict. The host expresses worry about anti-Semitic sentiments proliferating in America and criticizes the lack of intellectual arguments in current discourses. He raises concerns about the treatment of Jews in socio-political contexts and reflects on the shift in societal attitudes towards Jewish identity. The episode also touches on the host's past political inclinations and the evolution of his views, drawing parallels to aspects of Trumpism in his earlier writings.
Today's guest is Noam Dworman, the owner of New York's Comedy Cellar, the most influential—and controversial—comedy club on the planet. Dave Chapelle, Louis C.K., Amy Schumer, Sarah Silverman, Chris Rock, Andrew Schulz, and many others not only broke out from this club, but they also regularly return to try out new material. Trained as a lawyer, Dworman is a staunch defender of the First Amendment and, in an era of groveling apologies and censorship on the down low, he remains outspoken on the value and importance of free expression to a flourishing society. His podcast Live From the Table has guests ranging from Israel critic Norman Finkelstein to atheist Sam Harris to former Reasoners Radley Balko and Michael Moynihan—and never has a dull moment. Nick Gillespie talks with Dworman about free speech, the history of comedy in Greenwich Village, anti-Semitism, and Islamophobia.
00:00- Noam Dworman Highlights 00:30- Introduction 01:00- Dworman's Thriving Comedy Empire 08:24- Go Neither Woke Nor Broke 12:28- Dworman's Free Speech Roots 18:58- Tipper Gore's Censorship Crusade 21:49- When Did the Left Turn Against Free Speech? 24:57- Don't Censor Anti-Israel Speech Either! 27:49- Comedy Culture IS Free Speech Culture 30:41- Dworman's Father: Feuding With Bob Dylan 34:51- Dworman's Podcast: Live From the Table 37:33- That Viral Philip Bump Episode 41:50- Noam Dworman's Politics 43:53- Comedy During COVID 47:21- Free Speech Isn't A Given In All Comedy Clubs 49:11- Bringing Back Louis C.K. 53:38- Hosting Norman Finkelstein 57:06- Open Debate About Israel 1:12:12- Contemporary Antisemitism In America 1:15:40- AND ONE MORE THING!
Today's sponsors:
Better Help. Working with a therapist can help you get closer to the best version of you—because when you feel empowered, you're more prepared to take on everything life throws at you. Better Help is a great option. It's convenient, flexible, affordable, and entirely online. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist, and switch therapists anytime for no additional charge. Visit BetterHelp.com/TRI today to get 10 percent off your first month.
The Reason Roundtable Live in D.C.! Come out on Thursday, June 6 as Reason magazine's own Nick Gillespie, Katherine Mangu-Ward, Peter Suderman, and Matt Welch put their personal "free minds and free markets" filter on the biggest stories of the day. Tickets are $10 and going fast! Go here for details.
