Wisecrack Brett
30 snips
Sep 16, 2025 In this engaging discussion, Simon Spence, a Barrister and King's Counsel, reveals his pivotal role in the gripping case of Brett Rogers. He delves into the emotional turmoil surrounding a mother’s tragic murder and its impact on family dynamics. The complexities of mental health and rehabilitation are explored, alongside the intricacies of the legal battle that unfolded in court. Spence sheds light on the haunting details of the crime scene and the psychological factors influencing perceptions of guilt and sanity.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
A Violent Past With His Father
- Sam and others describe a prior violent incident where Brett beat his father so severely it dislodged an eyeball.
- Brett served 32 months for grievous bodily harm before later murdering his mother.
Trial Framed Mental State Narrowly
- Prosecutor Simon Spence framed Brett as violent but mentally fit after psychiatric reports failed to link illness to the killings.
- The trial focused on whether Brett acted alone and what his intention was at the time.
Defense Introduced An Alternate Suspect
- The defense later claimed Brett passed a man with a knife returning from the shop, creating doubt about direct guilt.
- Investigators still flagged an unexplained 45-minute gap between Brett's two 999 calls as suspicious but unevidenced.